FLORIDA TRIAL COUNSEL · REPRESENTING CLIENTS SINCE 1999Miami · Orlando · Gainesville · Pensacola   |   By appointment

Florida’s Property-Insurance Transparency Problem: Affiliate Transactions, Regulatory Secrecy, and the Public’s Right to Know

Florida map linking coastal homes, property policies, regulators, claims, and risk pools

By Jeffrey T. Donner, Esq.

September 23, 2026

Florida’s property-insurance crisis has produced years of extraordinary governmental intervention. The Legislature has rewritten significant portions of Florida insurance law, restricted assignments of post-loss benefits, substantially altered the attorney-fee rules governing property-insurance litigation, modified bad-faith remedies, created state-supported reinsurance programs, and expanded the regulatory apparatus intended to monitor insurer solvency. Much of this legislation was enacted on the premise that Florida’s insurance market faced a genuine structural crisis caused by hurricanes, reinsurance costs, litigation expenses, contractor practices, fraud, and the deteriorating financial condition of domestic insurers. Those explanations cannot simply be dismissed. Florida unquestionably presents substantial catastrophe risk, and several insurers have in fact failed.

But the public-policy debate cannot end there. If Florida is going to restructure private legal rights, deploy public resources to stabilize the insurance market, and repeatedly ask homeowners to accept substantial legislative changes for the supposed financial health of insurers, policymakers and the public are entitled to understand the financial relationships between those insurers and the affiliated companies operating alongside them. Recent disclosures concerning an Office of Insurance Regulation study suggest that those relationships deserve considerably more scrutiny than they historically received.

The controversy has now expanded beyond insurance regulation. According to reporting by the Orlando Sentinel and South Florida Sun Sentinel, the newspapers obtained previously undisclosed company-specific portions of the state’s insurance-affiliate analysis after the Florida Senate itself produced the documents in response to a public-records request. The Senate subsequently asserted that the disclosure had been inadvertent, demanded that the newspapers cease using the records and destroy all copies, and warned of possible “civil or criminal legal implications” if they refused. The newspapers refused.

That sequence creates at least three separate issues. The first concerns the economics of affiliated insurance companies and whether money can be moved within a corporate family in a manner that obscures the economic performance of the regulated insurer. The second concerns Florida’s regulatory system and whether the Office of Insurance Regulation has historically possessed—and exercised—adequate authority to evaluate those transactions. The third concerns open government and the extraordinary proposition that a state legislative body can provide documents to journalists through the public-records process and thereafter threaten legal consequences because the journalists intend to report what those documents reveal.

Those subjects should be analyzed separately because none requires accepting the most inflammatory interpretation of the others.

The affiliate problem is fundamentally a corporate-structure problem

A property insurer frequently does not operate as a completely self-contained corporation. Functions that a layperson might assume are performed inside the insurance company—including underwriting administration, claims administration, investment management, information technology, accounting, commissions, and management services—may instead be performed by legally distinct entities. Some of those entities are independent contractors. Others are affiliates under common ownership or control.

Managing general agents, commonly called MGAs, are particularly important to understanding the Florida market. An MGA can perform substantial functions traditionally associated with the insurer itself, including underwriting, pricing, policy administration, agent appointments, and claims-related services. An MGA can also be affiliated with the insurer, so that the entity paying for the service and the entity receiving the payment ultimately exist within the same larger corporate organization. The 2022 affiliate analysis found that 41 of the 53 insurers it reviewed used an MGA or attorney-in-fact to administer policy and claim operations.

None of this is inherently improper. Modern corporations routinely conduct business through subsidiaries and affiliated entities. A separate management company may centralize expertise, serve multiple operating subsidiaries, attract investment capital, or achieve administrative efficiencies that would be unavailable if every regulated insurer duplicated every function internally.

The regulatory concern arises from the conflict inherent in a related-party transaction. When an insurer purchases services from an unrelated vendor, each side ordinarily has an economic incentive to bargain over price. When an insurer and its service provider are under common ownership or common control, that arm’s-length discipline may be diminished. A dollar paid by the regulated insurer is an expense to that insurer, but the same dollar may constitute revenue to an affiliated company owned by substantially the same economic interests.

That distinction becomes especially important in insurance because the financial condition of the regulated insurance carrier has consequences that extend beyond its shareholders. The carrier must maintain sufficient capital and surplus to satisfy claims. Its financial results may be relevant to rate proceedings. Insolvency can ultimately implicate policyholders, guaranty mechanisms, other insurers, and the State of Florida itself. The question therefore is not whether affiliated transactions should exist, but whether they occur on terms consistent with the interests of the regulated insurer and its policyholders.

Florida law expressly recognizes that concern. Section 624.424(13), Florida Statutes, provides that an insurer paying a fee, commission, or other financial consideration to an affiliate must provide OIR, upon request, whatever information the office considers necessary. More importantly, the statute affirmatively requires that the payment be “fair and reasonable” and directs OIR to consider, among other things, the actual cost of the service being provided.

The statutory principle is therefore already established. The difficult questions concern measurement, enforcement, disclosure, and consequences.

What the state-commissioned analysis actually found

The underlying study was not produced by a consumer group, policyholder law firm, or political opposition organization. Florida’s Office of Insurance Regulation retained Risk & Regulatory Consulting, LLC to analyze fees paid by Florida domestic property insurers to affiliated entities. The analysis examined the 2017 through 2019 period and ultimately reviewed 53 insurers. Its executive summary is dated March 31, 2022.

The study’s aggregate numbers were extraordinary, although they must be interpreted carefully. The 53 insurers collectively reported approximately $61 million in net income during the three-year period. The study explained that even that number was substantially influenced by one insurer with approximately $493 million in net income; excluding that outlier, the remaining insurers collectively would have shown approximately $432 million in net losses. The affiliates providing services to the insurers, meanwhile, reported approximately $14 billion in net income. The report again identified outliers: excluding two national insurers, affiliate net income would have been approximately $1.8 billion.

Those figures should not be used irresponsibly. The $14 billion figure does not establish that Florida insurers transferred $14 billion of premiums to secretly profitable affiliated companies, and the differing corporate populations make simplistic insurer-versus-affiliate comparisons potentially misleading. The consultant itself identified outliers, incomplete data, capital contributions, fee forgiveness, debt-service expenses, and materially different business structures among the companies reviewed.

Yet the report becomes more significant, not less significant, when one moves beyond the headline number. It found that 19 of 35 single-state or regional insurers had affiliate fee structures considered “not-fair and reasonable,” with another five classified as undetermined because complete information had not been supplied. Of the 18 insurers associated with national insurance or service groups, one was placed in the “not-fair and reasonable” category and 11 were undetermined because of incomplete information.

The consultant also found that compensation under MGA agreements ranged from 20 percent to 34 percent of premium. When MGA compensation was combined with other affiliated fees for claims, commissions, investment management, and related services, total affiliated fees ranged from less than one percent to as much as 63 percent of premium. The report further observed that a majority of single-state and regional insurers appeared to use MGAs as a revenue stream for their holding companies.

Those findings do not establish wrongdoing by every company studied. They do establish why a regulator would want to examine affiliated transactions carefully.

Capital moved in both directions

The financial picture was also considerably more complicated than a one-way transfer of money from insurers to affiliates. The study found that affiliates waived approximately $208 million in fees and made approximately $951 million in capital contributions to insurers. Those facts matter because they demonstrate that affiliates sometimes supplied capital necessary to support the regulated carriers rather than merely extracting money from them.

At the same time, the report found that insurers paid approximately $680 million in dividends and another $48 million on surplus notes during the period, reducing the capital of 29 insurers by approximately $728 million. The consultant specifically recommended additional scrutiny of situations in which fee forgiveness and capital contributions were necessary to replenish depleted insurer capital or prevent regulatory intervention.

This is precisely why the affiliate issue cannot responsibly be reduced to the slogan that insurers “hid billions.” Corporate finance is more complicated. Money can move from the insurer to an affiliate through fees and dividends; money can move back through capital contributions or fee forgiveness; and different entities may carry different expenses, debt, tax obligations, and business operations.

But complexity is an argument for competent regulatory examination, not for opacity. If an insurer’s financial viability depends materially upon transactions among affiliated companies, regulators need enough information to follow those transactions through the entire corporate structure. Policyholders and legislators likewise have a legitimate interest in understanding the aggregate economic reality when major policy decisions are being justified by the regulated carrier’s reported financial distress.

The consultant itself identified shortcomings in the information available

Perhaps the most important part of the 2022 study is not its aggregate income figures. It is the consultant’s discussion of what it could not determine.

Several insurers did not provide complete information necessary to assess fully whether MGA and other affiliated agreements were reasonable. The consultant recommended that OIR obtain the missing information or conduct limited-scope examinations concerning affiliate transactions and expenses. It reported difficulty following intercompany transactions through Schedule Y filings for certain insurance holding-company systems and identified inconsistencies among annual-statement exhibits, financial-statement notes, Schedule Y disclosures, and audit reports. In some instances, related parties apparently were not identified as affiliates on the appropriate schedule.

The consultant also observed that a number of MGA agreements were at least ten years old. Some contained premium-based compensation provisions exceeding 25 percent, and the report recommended that insurers either revise such agreements or provide documentation and financial projections demonstrating that the fees remained fair and reasonable. The report further warned that MGA fee structures could potentially be used to circumvent restrictions applicable to insurer dividends.

That distinction is important. A dividend is transparently a distribution of corporate value to ownership. A service fee is ostensibly an operating expense incurred to purchase something the insurer needs. If a related company receives compensation materially exceeding the economic value of the service provided, a transaction labeled an “expense” can potentially produce an economic result resembling a distribution of profits.

Whether that occurred at any particular company requires company-specific evidence. The regulatory principle, however, is straightforward: labels should not control economic substance.

The secrecy surrounding the report created its own institutional problem

Another important fact is temporal. The executive summary was dated March 31, 2022, a period during which Florida’s property-insurance market was already in severe distress. Within months, the Legislature convened in special session and enacted major property-insurance legislation.

CS/SB 2-D, adopted during the May 2022 special session, made substantial changes to property-insurance litigation and regulation. Among other provisions, it restricted attorney-fee mechanisms, altered assignment-of-benefits litigation, established additional insurer reporting requirements, created the Property Insurance Stability Unit, and authorized the Reinsurance to Assist Policyholders program. That program provided a layer of state-supported reinsurance intended to stabilize the private market.

The fact that the affiliate analysis existed at the same time does not establish that individual legislators knew of it, much less that they intentionally ignored it. According to the Sentinel reporting, however, legislators later complained that the study had not been provided to them while they were considering the sweeping 2022 and 2023 reforms. OIR has subsequently characterized the consultant’s work as an unfinished draft containing errors, inconsistencies, data-validation problems, and outdated information. The regulator has also maintained that disclosure restrictions prevent it from publicly identifying many of the alleged errors.

That creates an epistemic problem for democratic government. A regulator may be entirely correct that a consultant’s analysis is flawed, but if the underlying data and the regulator’s detailed criticisms are themselves unavailable because of confidentiality restrictions, outsiders cannot independently evaluate the dispute. The public is effectively asked to accept the regulator’s conclusion about the reliability of evidence the public is prohibited from examining.

That may sometimes be unavoidable when genuine trade secrets are involved. It should not be treated as an unremarkable outcome.

Florida has unusually strong constitutional principles favoring open government

Florida’s public-records tradition is not merely statutory. Article I, section 24(a) of the Florida Constitution provides that every person has a right to inspect or copy public records made or received in connection with the official business of state government, expressly including the legislative, executive, and judicial branches. The Constitution permits the Legislature to create exemptions by general law, but requires such exemptions to be supported by a specifically stated public necessity and to be no broader than necessary to accomplish that purpose.

Florida’s Insurance Code contains significant confidentiality provisions. Section 624.4212 defines specified categories of “proprietary business information” and makes designated information held by OIR confidential and exempt from public disclosure. The protected categories include trade secrets, competitively sensitive information, certain contractual information, and internal audit material.

There are legitimate reasons for those protections. A regulated business does not lose every proprietary right merely because it operates in a regulated industry, and government agencies sometimes require confidential access to information that competitors should not receive. A statutory system that forced an insurer to publish genuine trade secrets as the price of regulatory compliance could itself impair competition and discourage candid disclosure to regulators.

The difficulty is drawing the boundary. “Trade secret” should not become a generic label permitting regulated entities or their regulator to conceal financial information simply because disclosure would be inconvenient or politically embarrassing. Conversely, public curiosity does not transform genuinely proprietary information into a public record. The legal system therefore must distinguish actual confidential business information from information whose public importance outweighs, or falls outside, the asserted confidentiality interest.

The Senate’s demand that the newspapers destroy the records raises a different constitutional issue

The newest controversy is legally distinct from the question whether OIR was initially entitled to withhold the material.

According to the Sentinel’s account, the newspapers made a broad request to the Florida Senate for legislative emails. One of the emails produced by the Senate contained PDF attachments comprising the complete affiliate analysis. OIR had apparently sent those materials to a Senate staff member in February 2025. The newspapers received them from the Senate months later as part of the Senate’s response to the records request.

After learning that the newspapers possessed the unredacted documents, Senate General Counsel Tom Thomas reportedly characterized their production as an inadvertent administrative error and issued what he called a “mandatory demand for compliance.” He demanded that the newspapers cease using the records, destroy or shred copies, direct any third parties who had received them to do likewise, and certify destruction within 48 hours. The newspapers refused.

Whatever the underlying status of the documents under Florida’s trade-secret statutes, attempting to impose civil or criminal consequences upon a newspaper that lawfully acquired truthful information from the government itself implicates a formidable line of United States Supreme Court precedent.

In Landmark Communications, Inc. v. Virginia, 435 U.S. 829 (1978), the Supreme Court invalidated the criminal punishment of a newspaper for publishing truthful information concerning confidential judicial-disciplinary proceedings. In Smith v. Daily Mail Publishing Co., 443 U.S. 97 (1979), the Court explained that when a newspaper lawfully obtains truthful information about a matter of public significance, punishment of publication requires a state interest of the highest order.

The analogy became even closer in Florida Star v. B.J.F., 491 U.S. 524 (1989). There, a Florida sheriff’s department mistakenly made a police report available to the press containing information state law sought to protect—the identity of a sexual-assault victim. The Supreme Court nevertheless held that imposing damages upon the newspaper for publishing truthful information it had lawfully obtained violated the First Amendment. The government’s own failure to safeguard the information was highly significant to the constitutional analysis.

And in Bartnicki v. Vopper, 532 U.S. 514 (2001), the Court protected publication of truthful information concerning a matter of public importance even though the original source had obtained the information unlawfully, because the publisher itself had not participated in the unlawful interception. That case did not create an unlimited constitutional privilege to publish every confidential document, but it reinforces the substantial First Amendment protection afforded to a publisher who lawfully receives information and then reports upon a matter of legitimate public concern.

The precise application of those authorities to the Senate’s demand would depend upon facts and legal arguments that have not yet been adjudicated. Trade secrets can implicate interests different from the privacy and confidentiality interests involved in some of those cases, and the scope of Florida’s applicable statutes would need to be analyzed carefully. Nevertheless, a governmental entity’s own production of documents to journalists through the public-records process presents a materially different situation from theft, computer intrusion, bribery, or participation in an unlawful acquisition.

Florida law itself illustrates the distinction. Section 815.04(3), Florida Statutes, makes it an offense to willfully and knowingly, and “without authorization,” disclose or take computer data constituting a trade secret or information made confidential by law; the ordinary offense is a third-degree felony. Whether that statute could constitutionally be applied to journalists who did not obtain the records through unauthorized computer access but instead received them directly from the Florida Senate pursuant to a records request presents a serious question quite apart from whether the Senate should have released the records in the first instance.

The 2026 Legislature had an opportunity to address the affiliate problem directly

The Legislature’s most recent treatment of affiliated transactions makes the episode still more significant.

In 2026, Representative Kimberly Berfield, a Republican, sponsored HB 1399, titled “Property Insurance Affiliates.” The legislation would have materially expanded OIR’s oversight of transactions between property insurers and related companies. It required insurers to provide documentation demonstrating that payments were fair and reasonable and directed OIR to consider such factors as the actual cost of services, the relative financial condition of the insurer and affiliate, debt, dividends, and whether contractual terms served the interests of the insurer and policyholders.

The legislation went considerably further. Affiliate agreements would have been subject to periodic review; OIR could restrict certain transfers during emergencies; affiliates could be required to refund improper payments; property-insurance affiliates would be subject to registration requirements; and OIR would receive enhanced enforcement authority. Most significantly from a rate-regulation perspective, the bill would have required OIR to consider affiliate profits, revenues, and investment income attributable or materially related to the insurer’s Florida business when evaluating property-insurance rates.

The Florida House passed HB 1399 on February 4, 2026, by a vote of 106 to 3. It was then transmitted to the Senate, referred to the Rules Committee, and died there when the session ended on March 13. A separate Senate proposal, SB 234, addressing insurer financial transactions died in the Senate Banking and Insurance Committee.

That history is important precisely because it defeats an overly simplistic partisan explanation. HB 1399 was sponsored by a Republican, and the Republican-controlled House overwhelmingly approved it. The Senate also has a Republican majority. The meaningful institutional question is therefore not whether “Republicans” uniformly opposed affiliate transparency—they plainly did not—but why legislation commanding overwhelming support in one Republican-controlled chamber never received a final vote in the other.

Political influence should be examined without pretending that campaign contributions prove bribery

No serious discussion of Florida insurance policy can ignore political money, but neither should campaign contributions be treated as proof of corruption.

The Florida Division of Elections identifies the Florida Insurance Council Political Committee as an active political committee. Aggregated 2026 campaign-finance data based on state filings reports approximately $547,000 in contributions to the committee and approximately $620,000 in expenditures during the cycle. Among the reported expenditures are substantial amounts directed to Republican candidates and political organizations, including $50,000 to the Florida Republican Senatorial Campaign Committee, while the committee also reported $10,000 to the Florida House Democratic Campaign Committee.

Those facts establish political participation; they do not establish a quid pro quo. Insurance is a massive industry whose businesses are directly affected by legislation, and participation in the political process through lawful contributions and lobbying is itself lawful. Businesses, trial lawyers, labor organizations, healthcare companies, developers, environmental organizations, and countless other interests engage in precisely the same process.

The proper question is therefore not whether a political contribution proves that an elected official has been “bought.” It does not. The more useful question is whether a political system in which highly regulated economic interests enjoy substantial access also maintains sufficiently strong institutions of disclosure, independent regulation, legislative oversight, and public scrutiny to allow citizens to evaluate the resulting policy.

That question becomes particularly important where government has already intervened heavily on the industry’s behalf. Public policy may legitimately favor measures designed to preserve a functioning private insurance market. But when the government restricts policyholders’ litigation remedies, changes attorney-fee rules, provides state-supported reinsurance, protects significant categories of insurer financial information from public disclosure, and then fails to enact proposed additional controls on affiliated transactions, scrutiny of the relationship between the regulated industry and government is hardly unreasonable.

The recent record also contains evidence favorable to the industry’s position

A complete analysis must acknowledge that Florida officials and insurers contend that the reforms are working.

The Sentinel reported that OIR Commissioner Michael Yaworsky has criticized the consultant’s affiliate analysis as outdated and methodologically defective. Insurers have also emphasized that the 2017–2019 period encompassed substantial claims activity associated with Hurricane Irma and other market stresses, and some companies have pointed to later capital contributions as evidence that corporate parents supported rather than drained their insurance subsidiaries. OIR and Republican legislative leaders have further pointed to new entrants into Florida’s property-insurance market and improving rate trends as evidence that the post-2022 reforms have helped stabilize the market.

Those developments are relevant. If Florida has attracted additional insurers, strengthened carrier solvency, and produced downward pressure on rates, policymakers are entitled to consider those results when evaluating earlier reforms. Nor does evidence that an affiliate earned substantial income necessarily establish that policyholders were overcharged or that an insurer’s rate was excessive.

But successful market stabilization would not answer the affiliate-transparency issue. A regulatory system can simultaneously produce improving market conditions and remain insufficiently transparent. Indeed, if the reforms have worked as proponents contend, greater disclosure of affiliate economics should make it easier—not harder—to demonstrate that the market’s improvement rests upon sustainable underwriting economics rather than opaque transfers among commonly controlled entities.

A problem of regulatory capitalism rather than conventional partisanship

The larger issue is not easily captured by the conventional opposition between “pro-business” and “anti-business” government. Florida has not adopted a laissez-faire property-insurance system. It has created an intensely regulated market in which government determines capital requirements, reviews rates, supervises solvency, regulates policy forms, controls market conduct, maintains residual-market mechanisms, provides extraordinary reinsurance support, and determines the legal rules under which insurers and policyholders may litigate disputes.

That is not a criticism; catastrophe insurance may require unusually substantial regulation. But once the state assumes that degree of responsibility for constructing the market, government cannot simultaneously claim that the economic relationships inside the regulated insurance groups are categorically none of the public’s concern.

A genuinely market-oriented approach should also recognize the problem of distorted incentives. Markets work best when prices reflect economic reality and parties bear the consequences of their decisions. If a regulated insurer can pay substantial premium-based fees to a commonly controlled affiliate while the carrier reports losses, seeks rate increases, or requires capital replenishment, regulators need to determine whether those fees represent the market value of genuine services or merely an allocation of economic value within the corporate family. That inquiry is not hostility toward capitalism. It is part of ensuring that the entity accepting policyholder premiums and promising to pay catastrophe losses remains adequately capitalized.

The 2022 consultant’s report did not finally answer those questions. In important respects, it demonstrated how many questions remained unanswered.

The most troubling part may be the government’s reaction to disclosure

Reasonable people can disagree about insurance regulation. They can disagree about litigation reform, attorney-fee statutes, assignments of benefits, rate regulation, state reinsurance, and how aggressively OIR should supervise affiliated transactions. They can also disagree about whether the consultant’s methodology fairly evaluated particular insurers.

The reaction to disclosure presents a more fundamental issue. Florida’s government commissioned the analysis. Florida government officials possessed it. The Florida Senate later produced the unredacted records to journalists responding to a public-records request. When the government realized what it had released, its response was not merely to say that the documents had been produced in error and explain why the underlying information remained legally protected. According to the newspapers, the Senate demanded destruction of the information and raised the possibility of criminal consequences if the journalists continued using it.

That posture deserves exacting legal scrutiny. The First Amendment cases do not establish that a newspaper has an absolute right to publish every piece of confidential information that comes into its possession. They do establish, however, a powerful constitutional principle protecting publication of truthful information concerning matters of public significance when the press lawfully obtained the information and did not participate in unlawfully acquiring it. Florida Star is especially difficult to ignore in a dispute arising in Florida from information that the government itself disclosed.

There is also a practical lesson. Government confidentiality regimes ultimately depend upon government protecting information before it is released. Once public employees produce a document in response to a lawful records request, attempting to transform the recipient’s continued possession and reporting into potential criminal conduct moves the controversy from ordinary public-records administration into constitutional territory.

Transparency is not the same thing as prejudgment

The case for greater disclosure does not require assuming that insurers committed fraud, that OIR deliberately concealed misconduct, or that legislators knowingly enacted laws for the benefit of campaign contributors. Those are factual propositions that require evidence.

The available evidence supports narrower but still consequential conclusions. OIR commissioned a substantial analysis of affiliate payments. That analysis identified numerous transactions its consultant regarded as inconsistent with the “fair and reasonable” standard, significant gaps in the information available for review, unusually high premium-based affiliate compensation in some cases, inconsistencies in financial reporting, and circumstances in which affiliate fee structures could potentially circumvent normal dividend restrictions. The analysis existed while Florida was undertaking major insurance reforms but was not publicly available in company-specific form.

In 2026, the Florida House overwhelmingly approved legislation designed to address many of those exact concerns. That legislation died in the Senate. Months later, journalists obtained the previously undisclosed company-specific information from the Senate itself, and the Senate responded by demanding that they destroy it.

Each individual event can be explained without resorting to conspiracy. Taken together, however, they present a serious public-policy problem concerning transparency and institutional accountability.

Florida can protect legitimate trade secrets without creating a black box

The appropriate response need not be wholesale public disclosure of every document submitted to an insurance regulator. Legitimate trade secrets should remain protected. Competitive pricing information, proprietary models, confidential technology, personal information, and other genuinely sensitive material may warrant confidentiality.

But there is an enormous middle ground between publishing every page in a regulator’s files and allowing the financial relationships among regulated insurers and their affiliates to become effectively inaccessible to the public. Aggregate affiliate payments, compensation methodologies, material related-party transactions, capital contributions, dividends, fee forgiveness, regulator determinations concerning reasonableness, and the effect of affiliated-company economics on rate filings are all subjects susceptible to meaningful disclosure without necessarily revealing every proprietary detail.

HB 1399 represented one legislative attempt to impose more structure upon that system. Whatever one thinks of every provision in that bill, its central premise was difficult to dispute: related-party transactions involving property insurers deserve a regulatory framework sufficiently rigorous to establish that payments are fair, reasonable, and consistent with policyholder interests. The House’s 106–3 vote demonstrates how broadly that proposition was accepted.

The unanswered question is why Florida has not yet converted that broad agreement into law.

Conclusion

Florida’s property-insurance debate has too often been presented as a choice among competing villains: insurance companies, plaintiffs’ lawyers, roofers, public adjusters, regulators, or politicians. That framing is analytically weak. Hurricanes impose enormous costs. Litigation can impose costs. Fraud can impose costs. Reinsurance can become extraordinarily expensive. Insurers also operate through complex corporate structures capable of transferring substantial amounts of money among related entities. More than one proposition can be true at the same time.

The obligation of government is therefore not to choose an industry narrative and defend it. It is to obtain reliable information, test competing explanations, regulate related-party transactions where necessary, and disclose enough information that legislators and citizens can determine whether the policies enacted in their names are justified by the underlying facts.

Florida’s own consultant raised serious questions about affiliated insurance transactions in 2022. The House attempted to strengthen oversight in 2026 and passed the resulting legislation by 106 votes to 3. The proposal nevertheless died in the Senate. When journalists later acquired previously undisclosed company-specific information through a records production from the Senate itself, the Senate demanded that they destroy it.

Those facts do not prove corruption. They do not establish that every affiliate payment was excessive. They do not establish that Florida’s insurance reforms were unnecessary or unsuccessful.

They establish something narrower, and sufficiently important on its own: Florida still has a substantial transparency problem in the regulation of one of the most economically consequential industries in the state.

The proper response to uncomfortable financial information is not to make it disappear. It is to determine what the information actually proves, what it does not prove, and whether the law adequately protects the people whose premiums ultimately finance the system.

First Party Property Law, Florida Constitution, Florida Constitutional Law, Government Abuse of Citizenry, Government Law, Insurance Company Bad Faith, Insurance Law, Real Property Law, Small Business Law
Call Donner Law Firm · 407-639-4223