FLORIDA TRIAL COUNSEL · REPRESENTING CLIENTS SINCE 1999Miami · Orlando · Gainesville · Pensacola   |   By appointment

The Return of the Forms: Crecelius v. Rizzitano, the Civil Jury, and Florida’s Retreat from Substantive Justice

Hiker walking along a sunlit trail through a dense evergreen forest

How an en banc decision of Florida’s Sixth District Court of Appeal exposes a deeper conflict between judicial case management, the adversarial system, and the constitutional purpose of civil litigation.

By Jeffrey T. Donner, Esq.

November 18, 2026

The right to a jury trial means considerably less if a court can prevent the jury from hearing material evidence because a lawyer failed to comply with a procedural deadline, without first considering whether the violation actually compromised the fairness of the proceeding.

That proposition lies at the center of a controversy created by the Sixth District Court of Appeal’s en banc decision in Crecelius v. Rizzitano, 430 So. 3d 268 (Fla. 6th DCA 2026). In an opinion expressly rejecting decades of precedent from Florida’s other district courts of appeal, the Sixth District held that a trial court may exclude an untimely disclosed expert witness or expert opinion without first determining whether its admission would prejudice the opposing party. The court reasoned that Florida’s longstanding approach to late-disclosed evidence rested on a fundamental misunderstanding of the Florida Supreme Court’s 1981 decision in Binger v. King Pest Control, 401 So. 2d 1310 (Fla. 1981). It certified conflict with sixteen decisions of its sister courts.

The decision deserves serious attention, both for what it holds and for the broader conception of civil litigation that it represents. The Sixth District did not merely resolve an evidentiary dispute. It articulated a philosophy of judicial administration in which enforcement of case-management deadlines can justify excluding material testimony independently of the prejudice traditionally associated with nondisclosure. That philosophy places the administrative requirements of litigation in tension with the substantive objectives those requirements were designed to serve.

The issue is not whether courts need deadlines. They plainly do. A civil justice system cannot operate if parties are free to disregard discovery obligations, conceal witnesses, or force their opponents to prepare for trial without adequate information. But the necessity of procedural rules does not answer the more important question: When a rule is violated, should the court’s primary objective be to vindicate its authority, or to determine whether the violation can be addressed while preserving a fair adjudication of the parties’ claims and defenses?

Florida’s constitutional guarantees, its procedural history, and the traditional premises of the adversarial system suggest that the answer should ordinarily favor adjudication on a developed evidentiary record. Crecelius moves in a different direction. Its significance becomes apparent when the decision is considered against the larger evolution of civil practice: a system that formally abolished technical pleading requirements has increasingly surrounded substantive litigation with layers of procedural prescriptions, administrative directives, electronic-filing protocols, and judge-specific practices.

What began as an effort to simplify litigation risks becoming a system in which procedural compliance is treated as an achievement separate from, and sometimes superior to, the resolution of disputes.

The Forgotten Revolution: The Abolition of Technical Forms

Modern civil procedure was built on a rejection of the proposition that a litigant should lose an otherwise meritorious case because counsel selected the wrong procedural form.

Historically, common-law pleading was notoriously technical. The forms of action determined the remedies available, the allegations required, and frequently the outcome of litigation. A party with a substantively valid grievance could nevertheless fail because the claim had been presented through an incorrect procedural vehicle. The movement toward modern civil procedure sought to eliminate that artificial distinction between procedural correctness and substantive entitlement.

Florida’s rules still embody this reform.

Florida Rule of Civil Procedure 1.040 establishes a single form of civil action. More significantly, Rule 1.110(a) expressly abolishes technical forms for obtaining relief and for presenting pleas, pleadings, and motions. Rule 1.100(b) generally requires a motion to identify its grounds with particularity and specify the relief sought. These provisions reflect an intentional preference for substance over ritual: the court should understand what relief is requested and why, without demanding adherence to a ceremonial formula.

The governing philosophy is reinforced by Rule 1.010, which instructs courts to construe the civil rules to secure the just, speedy, and inexpensive determination of every action. The three objectives are stated together. Justice is not an optional benefit to be pursued after administrative efficiency has been achieved; nor is efficiency irrelevant to the administration of justice. The rules contemplate that these interests will inform one another.

Yet anyone who has practiced civil litigation for a substantial period recognizes a striking contradiction between these principles and the increasingly elaborate administrative requirements of modern practice.

A lawyer may prepare a legally sufficient motion, only to discover that a particular judicial division expects different language, a specific caption, a prescribed form of certification, an additional cover document, or a proposed order complying with formatting conventions not apparent from the statewide procedural rules. A filing may then require further revision because the proposed order was submitted through the wrong electronic procedure or because a judicial practice manual expresses a preference for particular wording.

Not every such requirement is improper. Standardized electronic procedures can improve efficiency, facilitate access to documents, and reduce genuine administrative burdens. Some requirements are expressly authorized by rule, and others are legitimate exercises of a court’s case-management authority. But their proliferation raises a jurisprudential question that receives surprisingly little attention: At what point does the cumulative burden of procedural standardization recreate the very formalism that modern pleading rules were designed to abolish?

The resemblance is functional rather than historical. Today’s practitioner is not required to select among medieval writs. Nevertheless, a lawyer who must repeatedly consult division-specific instructions to determine the permissible wording and formatting of an otherwise straightforward motion encounters a modern version of the same problem. The procedural container becomes a separate object of professional labor, sometimes with little relationship to the substantive question before the court.

This is not an argument that Rule 1.110(a) prohibits all forms, templates, or administrative practices. It plainly does not. A rule abolishing technical forms cannot reasonably be read as eliminating the court’s authority to regulate filings. The more sophisticated argument is one of interpretive priority: when courts exercise that authority, they should do so consistently with the procedural system’s deliberate rejection of unnecessary technical barriers.

A rule designed to help the court understand a request is fundamentally different from a requirement that exists principally because a particular judge prefers a particular formulation. The former serves adjudication. The latter may serve convenience, but convenience alone should not be mistaken for substantive justice.

Crecelius presents a more consequential version of this tension. Instead of addressing the wording of a motion, it concerns the exclusion of expert testimony that might affect a jury’s determination of fault. The underlying question, however, is the same: whether procedural requirements remain instruments of justice or become independent determinants of who may prevail.

The Sixth District’s Extraordinary Reinterpretation of Binger

The factual circumstances of Crecelius do not present an especially sympathetic example of diligent pretrial practice.

The case arose from a fatal collision between an automobile and a motorcycle. The estate of the deceased motorcyclist sued the automobile driver for negligence. A central issue was comparative fault, including whether the motorcyclist had been traveling at an excessive speed. The defendant retained an accident reconstruction expert and a human-factors expert whose opinions supported his theory that the motorcyclist’s conduct contributed to the collision.

The defendant, however, failed to comply with the applicable expert-disclosure deadlines. Although the parties agreed to extend one deadline to March 18, 2024, the defendant did not identify his experts until April 10. Their substantive opinions were not provided until late May, shortly before a trial scheduled to begin June 18. The trial judge had already allowed substantial time for preparation. At the hearing on the motion to exclude the experts, defense counsel acknowledged that the late disclosures prejudiced the plaintiff.

Significantly, the trial court did not simply exclude the experts because a deadline had passed. It expressly found that permitting their testimony would prejudice the plaintiff. The court also considered the extended history of missed deadlines, the defendant’s explanations for the delay, and the disruption associated with postponing a trial that had been pending for more than two years.

The trial court excluded both experts. The jury subsequently found the defendant entirely responsible for the accident and returned a verdict of $8.25 million. On appeal, the Sixth District affirmed the exclusion.

That result may well have been justified under the traditional Binger analysis. The delay was substantial, the missing opinions concerned a central issue of causation, the plaintiff’s expert reportedly lacked sufficient time to prepare a completed rebuttal analysis, and the trial was imminent. The record also raised legitimate questions about the defendant’s diligence. A prejudice-based framework did not require the appellate court to excuse these failures.

Indeed, Crecelius is an unusual vehicle for declaring that a prejudice inquiry is unnecessary. The trial judge actually conducted such an inquiry and found prejudice. An affirmance under the established Binger framework was therefore available without changing the governing law. That circumstance does not make the Sixth District’s broader holding impermissible, but it raises a legitimate question about the necessity and prudence of the court’s doctrinal departure.

Nevertheless, the Sixth District chose to announce a considerably broader rule.

What Binger actually decided

In Binger, the Florida Supreme Court confronted the problem of a witness who had not been disclosed as required by a pretrial order. The plaintiffs attempted to introduce an undisclosed impeachment expert at trial. The trial court permitted the testimony, but the Florida Supreme Court concluded that the defendant had been unfairly prejudiced by the nondisclosure and approved the decision granting a new trial.

The Court emphasized the broad discretion of trial judges while identifying considerations that should guide their response to nondisclosure. The central consideration was actual prejudice, meaning surprise affecting trial preparation rather than the mere fact that testimony would be unfavorable. Additional factors included the ability to cure the prejudice, the nondisclosing party’s possible bad faith, and disruption of the orderly trial of the case.

The framework reflected a practical understanding of litigation. A previously undisclosed witness might cause genuine unfairness, particularly when the opposing party had no meaningful opportunity to investigate or respond. But nondisclosure would not necessarily have that effect in every case. An opponent might already know the witness, possess the relevant materials, have an opportunity to conduct discovery, or be able to address the testimony without delaying trial.

The purpose of the inquiry was to distinguish a violation that materially impaired fairness from one that, although improper, did not justify depriving the factfinder of relevant evidence.

For approximately forty-five years, Florida’s district courts generally understood Binger to require consideration of prejudice when determining whether to exclude an undisclosed or late-disclosed witness. The analysis was also extended to materially changed expert opinions and, in various circumstances, undisclosed exhibits. See, e.g., State Farm Mutual Automobile Insurance Co. v. Thorne, 110 So. 3d 66 (Fla. 2d DCA 2013); Gaspar’s Passage, LLC v. RaceTrac Petroleum, Inc., 243 So. 3d 492 (Fla. 2d DCA 2018).

The Sixth District concluded that these courts had expanded Binger beyond its binding holding.

Relying on Pedroza v. State, 291 So. 3d 541 (Fla. 2020), the majority distinguished a judicial holding from dictum by examining the propositions actually decided along the court’s chosen path of reasoning from the facts to the judgment. Because Binger involved a trial court’s erroneous admission of an undisclosed witness, the Sixth District reasoned that the Florida Supreme Court’s discussion of the conditions under which an undisclosed witness should be allowed to testify did not establish a binding restriction on a trial judge’s authority to exclude one.

Accordingly, the Sixth District held that a trial court may enforce a disclosure deadline by excluding the late-disclosed evidence without making a preliminary finding that admission would prejudice the opponent.

This reasoning is intellectually serious. Appellate courts must distinguish holdings from dicta, and they are not required to perpetuate an interpretation of precedent merely because that interpretation has become familiar. The Sixth District also identified an important passage in Binger that is often overlooked: the Florida Supreme Court acknowledged local pretrial practices, including orders that expressly prohibited testimony by witnesses not disclosed within a prescribed period.

That passage supplies a substantial argument for the Sixth District. The Supreme Court recognized that trial courts possess meaningful authority to administer their pretrial orders and did not prescribe an inflexible statewide system for every disclosure dispute. A serious critique of Crecelius must confront that language rather than simply repeating the conventional prejudice test.

But the passage does not necessarily establish what the Sixth District takes it to establish.

In the same discussion, Binger qualified the operation of local practices by reference to the governing principles of its decision and the objectives of discovery. Recognition that some courts issue strict pretrial orders is not necessarily an endorsement of mechanical exclusion in circumstances where no unfairness would result from admission. Indeed, if strict exclusion operated independently of all fairness considerations, the Supreme Court’s substantial discussion of prejudice, cure, bad faith, and disruption would become a remarkably limited exercise.

The better reading is that Binger established broad trial-court discretion informed by the actual consequences of nondisclosure. The precise boundary between binding holding and persuasive guidance may be debatable, but the decision’s orientation toward practical fairness is difficult to mistake.

The danger of reducing a precedent to its narrowest facts

The Sixth District’s approach also raises a question about the nature of appellate precedent.

A supreme court frequently announces a general rule while resolving a particular dispute. The fact that a case involves an erroneous admission does not automatically mean the announced standard lacks application to an erroneous exclusion. Admission and exclusion are alternative outcomes of the same evidentiary determination. A test addressing the exercise of discretion in that determination may therefore be broader than the precise disposition in the original case.

Importantly, Pedroza does not require appellate courts to reduce every holding to the narrowest possible factual proposition. Its inquiry concerns the reasoning actually adopted on the path to judgment. The difficult question is whether the Florida Supreme Court, in Binger, actually adopted a general framework governing both sides of the admission-or-exclusion decision.

Judge Jared Smith, concurring in the result only in Crecelius, concluded that it had. He examined the issue as Binger framed it, the conflicting district court decisions the Supreme Court sought to reconcile, and the breadth of the test the Supreme Court announced. Several of the cases considered in Binger involved excluded witnesses. From that perspective, the majority’s distinction between admitting and excluding evidence arguably understates the scope of the problem the Supreme Court intended to resolve.

Judge Smith nevertheless agreed that the exclusion in Crecelius should be affirmed under Binger. That agreement is especially significant. It demonstrates that adherence to the established prejudice analysis would not have changed the result. The en banc majority’s broader rejection of the prevailing doctrine was a jurisprudential choice, not an unavoidable consequence of the case’s facts.

There is a substantial difference between holding that a trial judge acted within permissible discretion in excluding experts disclosed shortly before trial and holding that Florida courts have misunderstood the Supreme Court’s governing framework for nearly half a century.

The former resolves a dispute. The latter reconstructs the law.

A Trial Is Not a Compliance Audit

The adversarial trial is an unusual institution. Rather than assigning a government official the task of deciding every contested fact through investigation, it relies on competing parties to present evidence, challenge opposing proof, and persuade an independent factfinder. Its legitimacy derives partly from the opportunity to test factual assertions in public, through witnesses who can be questioned and arguments that can be answered.

That model requires procedural rules. It does not, however, assume that testimony is legitimate only when its precise content has been reduced to a pretrial disclosure.

This distinction is particularly important with expert witnesses.

An expert’s opinion is not a static computer file. It is a professional judgment formed from facts, assumptions, methods, and experience. An expert may clarify an opinion in response to a question, acknowledge an additional qualification, correct an error, or explain that a previously stated conclusion depends on assumptions that have changed. The possibility of such developments is one reason expert testimony is ordinarily tested through deposition and cross-examination.

The law should distinguish between a genuinely new theory that unfairly deprives an opponent of preparation and the normal refinement, clarification, or testing of an opinion through testimony. Treating every meaningful variation as a disclosure violation risks transforming expert witnesses into performers required to recite an approved script.

That would be a misunderstanding of what testimony is.

The traditional courtroom has several mechanisms for addressing surprise or uncertainty: voir dire of the witness, cross-examination, impeachment with prior testimony, objections directed to particular opinions, limiting instructions, supplemental discovery, and, when necessary, a continuance. Florida law recognizes the importance of examining the basis of expert opinions. See § 90.705, Fla. Stat. That statute governs the presentation and examination of expert testimony; it does not displace otherwise applicable pretrial disclosure requirements. The broader point is that the adversarial system ordinarily tests the reliability of evidence through examination and rebuttal rather than advance certification alone.

Cross-examination, however, is not a universal cure. A lawyer cannot effectively confront a complex new engineering analysis simply by asking forceful questions if the analysis requires independent calculations, additional records, or consultation with another expert. A previously undisclosed accident reconstruction model may present precisely the kind of surprise that meaningful pretrial discovery is designed to prevent.

The answer is therefore neither unrestricted trial by ambush nor automatic exclusion for technical noncompliance. It is a disciplined inquiry into what the opposing party actually needs to respond fairly and whether that opportunity can reasonably be provided.

Consider two situations.

In the first, an expert disclosed months before trial explains an existing opinion somewhat differently on the witness stand. The essential theory is unchanged; the underlying materials are familiar; and opposing counsel has the deposition transcript, documents, and technical background needed to challenge the explanation. Excluding the testimony merely because every formulation was not anticipated in a disclosure would elevate form over substance.

In the second, an expert reveals for the first time, days before trial, a fundamentally different causation model requiring new measurements and technical analysis. The opposing expert cannot reasonably respond without substantial additional work, and trial cannot proceed fairly on the existing schedule. Exclusion may then be entirely appropriate.

The distinction is not elusive. It turns on the actual litigation consequences of the disclosure failure.

The enduring appeal of courtroom narratives such as My Cousin Vinny, A Few Good Men, and Matlock is not that they accurately portray every discovery obligation. They do not. Their appeal lies in a more fundamental ideal: that the decisive moment in litigation should involve a witness being questioned, a proposition being tested, and a factfinder confronting the evidence. The lawyer’s ability to expose an unreliable assumption or an inconsistency can change the outcome.

That ideal is not merely cinematic nostalgia. It is a recognizable feature of the common-law adversarial tradition.

The image of two skilled advocates—an Abraham Lincoln and an Atticus Finch, so to speak—presenting competing versions of the facts may be romanticized, but it conveys an essential institutional choice. The parties should ordinarily be able to develop their positions through evidence, examination, and argument before those positions are resolved by the designated factfinder.

A civil trial should not become an administrative audit in which the decisive inquiry is whether every component of a witness’s testimony appeared in precisely the right document by precisely the right date.

The Constitutional Problem: Preserving the Jury in Form While Diminishing It in Practice

The deepest concern raised by Crecelius is constitutional in character, even if it does not establish a straightforward constitutional violation.

The Seventh Amendment preserves the civil jury in federal proceedings within its historical scope. Florida’s Constitution independently protects the right of trial by jury in article I, section 22, and guarantees access to courts in article I, section 21. The Seventh Amendment has not been incorporated against the states; Florida’s own constitutional guarantee therefore provides the principal civil-jury protection in Florida state courts. See Minneapolis & St. Louis Railroad Co. v. Bombolis, 241 U.S. 211 (1916).

These guarantees must not be reduced to ceremonial statements. The constitutional role of the jury includes determining disputed facts in cases properly triable to a jury. When a court excludes material evidence, it necessarily shapes the factual record the jury is permitted to consider.

That authority is both indispensable and consequential.

Judges routinely exclude evidence under valid evidentiary rules. Irrelevant evidence, privileged communications, unreliable expert testimony, and evidence excluded for other lawful reasons do not become admissible merely because a party invokes the jury-trial right. Nor does every erroneous evidentiary ruling amount to a constitutional deprivation. The jury right has always existed within a framework of judicial supervision.

Still, the existence of lawful evidentiary restrictions should not obscure an important difference between excluding testimony because it is legally inadmissible and excluding it because counsel failed to complete a procedural obligation on time.

A relevant, reliable expert opinion may bear directly on a disputed issue of comparative negligence. If it is excluded, the jury may be asked to resolve fault without hearing evidence that could materially affect its conclusion. In practical terms, the court has narrowed the range of factual explanations available to the jury, even though the underlying dispute remains one that the jury is constitutionally entrusted to decide.

The constitutional right may survive formally while its practical significance is diminished.

This concern becomes especially acute when exclusion is treated as an acceptable consequence of noncompliance without an inquiry into the necessity of that consequence. If the opposing party is not surprised, requires no additional preparation, and can fairly address the testimony, what substantive interest is served by keeping it from the jury? The answer cannot rest solely on the proposition that a deadline was violated. The court must also account for what is lost when otherwise admissible proof is withheld.

This is best understood as a constitutional-values argument and an interpretive principle, rather than a claim that Crecelius is necessarily unconstitutional on its face. Florida courts possess authority to impose lawful consequences for discovery violations. The stronger position is that, where the governing rules leave room for discretion, judges should interpret and exercise that discretion with appropriate respect for access to courts, the jury’s factfinding function, and the preference for deciding disputes on their merits.

A related distinction concerns summary judgment.

Florida Rule of Civil Procedure 1.510 permits summary judgment when the applicable legal standard is satisfied, including the absence of a genuine dispute of material fact. That procedure does not offend the jury-trial principle simply because it prevents an unnecessary trial; a jury is not constitutionally required to decide a factual dispute that does not genuinely exist. But a case in which material evidence is excluded for a procedural violation presents a different problem. The dispute may be genuine. The evidence may be relevant. The jury’s inability to hear it may stem from a sanction rather than from the legal insufficiency of the underlying claim or defense.

That distinction matters. The proper function of procedure is to identify which factual issues require adjudication and to establish fair conditions for resolving them. Procedure becomes more troubling when its operation determines which material facts the jury will never be allowed to consider for reasons unrelated to the evidence’s substantive quality or to any demonstrated unfairness.

Florida appellate decisions have recognized the seriousness of excluding important witnesses. In Gaspar’s Passage, the Second District emphasized the need for a proper prejudice analysis before excluding crucial defense testimony. The Second District reaffirmed that concern in Avesta Communities, LLC v. Fred, No. 2D2025-0367 (Fla. 2d DCA Mar. 25, 2026), reversing the exclusion of a witness at an evidentiary hearing where the opponent already knew of the witness and possessed relevant information. Avesta involved a different procedural setting, not a jury trial with late-disclosed technical experts, but it illustrates the continuing force of the fairness-based approach outside the Sixth District.

The constitutional question is therefore not whether judges may regulate trials. They must. It is whether courts should regard exclusion of substantial evidence as an ordinary administrative response, or as a serious measure requiring justification proportionate to the harm it prevents.

A system committed to jury adjudication should choose the latter orientation wherever the governing law permits it.

The Administrative State Within the Courthouse

The growth of procedural formalism is not confined to witness disclosures. Crecelius is part of a larger institutional development in which civil practice has become increasingly governed by multiple, overlapping sources of administrative instruction.

A Florida litigator must consult applicable statutes, statewide procedural rules, evidentiary rules, ethical rules, local rules adopted through the appropriate process, circuit-wide administrative orders, division procedures, standing orders, electronic-filing instructions, and judicial preferences published on court websites. Some of these requirements govern important rights. Others concern the manner in which an attorney communicates with judicial staff or submits a proposed order.

These sources do not occupy the same level of legal authority, and they should not be treated as interchangeable. Florida Rule of General Practice and Judicial Administration 2.120 distinguishes among categories of court rules and administrative directives, while Rule 2.215 governs their implementation within the trial courts. Significantly, Rule 2.215(f) permits individual and divisional practices but expressly prohibits such practices from contradicting established law or procedural rules. The fact that an instruction appears on a judicial webpage does not itself make the instruction equivalent to a rule promulgated by the Florida Supreme Court.

The distinction is easy to state but can be difficult to maintain in everyday practice.

A lawyer generally cannot afford to ignore a judge’s published procedures while litigating the scope of that judge’s authority. Even where a particular preference appears unnecessary, the practical cost of challenging it may vastly exceed the cost of complying. The rational response is often to spend time learning and accommodating the preference, regardless of whether it advances the client’s substantive interests.

Multiply that response across numerous cases, multiple circuits, and judges with different submission procedures, and the burden becomes significant.

The consequences are particularly pronounced for solo practitioners and small firms. A lawyer with a large institutional client base may have administrative personnel, litigation-support specialists, and standardized internal systems to absorb recurring procedural tasks. A smaller practice may depend on one lawyer and a limited staff to manage every aspect of representation, including court filings, client communications, discovery, billing, collection, scheduling, technology, and trial preparation.

The same administrative requirement does not impose the same practical burden on every practitioner.

This is not an argument that small-firm lawyers should receive a separate set of procedural rules or that professional workloads excuse noncompliance. Every lawyer assumes duties of diligence and competence. Rather, it is a reminder that procedural design has distributional consequences. Administrative requirements consume resources, and those resources must come from somewhere: the lawyer’s time, the client’s funds, or the effort otherwise available for factual investigation and substantive analysis.

The burden is not simply inconvenience. It affects the economics of access to legal representation.

The ordinary motion that became an administrative project

Consider a straightforward motion to withdraw from representation because a client has substantially failed to meet an obligation to counsel despite reasonable warning.

The legal framework is serious but understandable. Rule Regulating The Florida Bar 4-1.16(b)(3) permits withdrawal in specified circumstances involving a client’s substantial failure to fulfill an obligation to the lawyer. Subdivision (c) requires compliance with applicable law concerning notice to or permission from the tribunal, and subdivision (d) requires measures reasonably practicable to protect the client’s interests. Florida Rule of General Practice and Judicial Administration 2.505(f)(1) imposes particular requirements for withdrawal by court order, including the reasons for withdrawal and the client’s last-known contact information.

Those obligations serve legitimate purposes. Withdrawal can prejudice a litigant, delay proceedings, or leave important matters unattended. A judge must be able to determine whether withdrawal is appropriate, ensure that required notice has been given, and protect the orderly administration of the case. Moreover, the existence of good cause does not itself terminate counsel’s appearance; an attorney must comply with applicable requirements for withdrawal and continue representation if ordered to do so.

But once those substantive and rule-based requirements have been satisfied, the additional demand that counsel reproduce a particular judge’s preferred phrasing or proposed-order format should be examined critically. The law requires an adequate motion. It does not follow that every motion must imitate the exact wording of a website template to be legally sufficient.

The distinction is between a motion that omits information the governing rules require and a motion that conveys that information in an unfamiliar but adequate form.

The former may properly be rejected or corrected. The latter should generally be evaluated on its merits.

A judge may reasonably prescribe administrative procedures that facilitate the preparation and entry of orders. Yet a system in which an attorney must devote disproportionate time to discovering and reproducing those preferences is not necessarily becoming more efficient. It may merely be transferring administrative labor from the court to private practitioners, who must then absorb or pass along the cost.

Nor should procedural burdens be evaluated only one requirement at a time. An additional certificate, formatting convention, cover sheet, or electronic-submission instruction may appear trivial in isolation. The cumulative effect of hundreds of such tasks is not trivial.

For lawyers, time devoted to clerical compliance is time unavailable for preparing witnesses, analyzing legal issues, communicating with clients, investigating facts, and attempting settlement. For clients, the result may be higher fees or reduced access to counsel. For the legal system, the cost may be a profession increasingly rewarded for administrative adaptation rather than the skills most closely associated with obtaining a just result.

The irony is difficult to overlook: a procedural system originally designed to abolish technical forms risks becoming more technically demanding even as its capacity to conduct substantive trials diminishes.

Strict Enforcement Is Not the Same as Substantive Justice

The Sixth District’s position cannot be fairly evaluated without acknowledging the genuine problems it seeks to address.

Civil discovery has become expensive, complex, and time-consuming. Late disclosures can undermine months of preparation. A party who receives an expert’s new theory shortly before trial may have to choose among inadequate preparation, substantial additional expense, and a continuance that postpones resolution for months. Those costs can be especially unfair when the receiving party complied with every deadline and the nondisclosing party did not.

Trial judges also manage crowded calendars. A continuance does not affect only the parties before the court; it can displace other litigants waiting for trial. An approach that permits routinely late disclosures may encourage gamesmanship and weaken legitimate expectations created by case-management orders.

These are powerful considerations. They are not mere expressions of judicial impatience.

Indeed, Binger itself recognizes them. Its prejudice analysis includes the possibility of disruption to the orderly and efficient trial of the case and to other cases. A court applying Binger faithfully is not required to overlook the institutional costs of nondisclosure. It may consider them as part of determining what fairness requires.

The central objection to Crecelius is therefore not that the Sixth District values efficient case management. It is that the decision separates the authority to exclude evidence from a required finding of prejudice, thereby creating room for exclusion based on procedural noncompliance even where the evidence could be admitted without materially compromising the opposing party’s preparation or the court’s schedule.

There is an additional complication: Florida’s civil rules changed substantially on January 1, 2025.

Under the amended Rule 1.200(d)(3), a case-management order must state that its deadlines will be strictly enforced unless changed by court order. Rule 1.200(e)(1) repeats the strict-enforcement requirement, while other provisions establish procedures for requesting modifications. These amendments represent a deliberate effort by the Florida Supreme Court to strengthen case management and reduce avoidable delay.

Separately, amended Rule 1.380(d) addresses failures to provide information or identify witnesses as required by Rule 1.280(a) or (g). It provides for exclusion of information or witnesses within its scope unless the failure was substantially justified or harmless. That is a materially different formulation from the traditional Binger prejudice inquiry, and it creates a distinct, textually specified basis for preclusion.

A responsible analysis must take these developments seriously. The current rules are not identical to those under which Binger was decided.

Nevertheless, several distinctions remain essential.

First, the relevant disclosure events in Crecelius occurred in 2024. The Sixth District’s holding therefore concerned the authority available under the earlier procedural framework. Later amendments may illuminate the Supreme Court’s present case-management policy, but they do not automatically establish the meaning of the rules governing earlier proceedings.

Second, the procedural posture limits the significance of the decision. Under the version of Rule 1.200(d) governing the 2024 proceedings, a case-management order could be modified to prevent injustice. The Sixth District acknowledged this provision but concluded that the defendant could not invoke it because he had not sought a further extension of the expert-disclosure deadline. The court also found no basis in the record to conclude that a modification was necessary to prevent injustice.

That omission matters. A party requesting relief from an approaching deadline presents a materially different question from a party who disregards the deadline and seeks admission of evidence only after the opponent moves to exclude it. The distinction supports requiring lawyers to request timely modifications while preserving a meaningful judicial inquiry into whether modification is appropriate.

Third, strict enforcement of a deadline does not, by itself, answer every question concerning the appropriate consequence of a violation. A rule requiring compliance may authorize sanctions, but the nature and severity of those sanctions must still be determined by the governing text. Rule 1.380(d), for example, expressly addresses evidentiary preclusion and specifies exceptions. Rule 1.200’s direction to enforce deadlines should be read in conjunction with the rest of the procedural framework, rather than treated as an unlimited invitation to disregard the significance of excluded evidence.

Finally, even a rule that places substantial weight on enforcement does not eliminate the distinction between deliberate concealment, reckless disregard, ordinary negligence, a genuinely unforeseeable development, and an immaterial technical lapse. Where the applicable rule makes justification or harmlessness relevant, those distinctions can be decisive. Where judicial discretion remains, they should inform its exercise.

The appropriate approach is proportionality rather than indulgence.

A trial judge confronted with a late disclosure should identify the importance of the evidence, the nature and explanation of the violation, the extent of actual surprise, the reasonable availability of a cure, the costs imposed on the opposing party, and the effects on the trial schedule. Exclusion should be more readily available when a violation is willful, repeated, strategically motivated, or incapable of cure. A substantially different expert theory disclosed on the eve of trial may warrant exclusion even without evidence of subjective bad faith.

By contrast, where the opponent already knows the substance of the evidence and admission can occur without genuine unfairness or disruption, exclusion may be a disproportionate response—unless a specific procedural rule directs otherwise.

This approach does not permit lawyers to treat deadlines as suggestions. It requires them to comply, to seek extensions through the procedures the rules prescribe, and to bear appropriate consequences when they fail. It also requires courts to recognize that the purpose of those consequences is to protect fair adjudication, not simply to demonstrate that noncompliance has a price.

A missed deadline is a procedural event. Exclusion of potentially dispositive testimony is a substantive consequence. The relationship between them should be explained, not assumed.

Why the Florida Supreme Court Should Reconsider Crecelius

The Florida Supreme Court has a compelling reason to address the conflict created by Crecelius. The Sixth District expressly certified disagreement with sixteen decisions of other district courts, producing an unusually direct divergence over a frequently recurring issue of civil practice.

The Court has already accepted review of a related certified-conflict case, Wal-Mart Stores East, L.P. v. Wynn, Supreme Court Case No. SC2026-0611. Review was granted on August 3, 2026. Wynn applied Crecelius to the exclusion of a late-disclosed expert opinion, and Judge Smith again expressed disagreement with the Sixth District’s departure from the traditional Binger analysis. As of November 18, 2026, no final Florida Supreme Court decision resolving that conflict had been identified. The grant of review in Wynn should not be confused with a verified grant of direct review in Crecelius itself.

The Supreme Court’s task will be more difficult than deciding whether it prefers strict deadlines or flexible trial management. Both policies have legitimate claims.

At least four issues warrant examination.

The first is the precedential scope of Binger. Did the Court establish a single framework governing trial-court discretion over undisclosed witnesses, or did its binding holding concern only the improper admission of testimony that prejudiced an objecting party? The Sixth District’s analysis under Pedroza presents one answer. Judge Smith’s concurrence presents another. The Supreme Court is uniquely positioned to clarify the intended reach of its own precedent.

Second, the Court should consider the significance of the longstanding, nearly uniform interpretation adopted by the district courts. Forty-five years of consistent application do not make an erroneous interpretation correct. But settled judicial construction carries institutional weight, particularly when litigants and trial judges have organized their conduct around it. If the Supreme Court believes a major doctrinal correction is appropriate, it can identify the correction explicitly and address its relationship to the revised procedural rules.

Third, the Court should distinguish the different categories of disclosure problems that have been grouped under Binger. Failure to identify a witness, failure to disclose a known expert opinion, material alteration of an opinion, and an ordinary clarification during testimony are not necessarily equivalent. The legal analysis should be capable of recognizing their differences rather than treating all departures from advance disclosure as interchangeable.

Fourth, the Court should explain the interaction between Rules 1.200 and 1.380(d). The 2025 amendments demand serious compliance with case-management deadlines and create an express exclusionary consequence for certain disclosure failures, subject to stated exceptions. The Court can clarify whether, and to what extent, those rules displace the earlier Binger framework; when separate prejudice findings remain necessary; and what discretion trial judges retain when applying the rules to circumstances not expressly covered by the new exclusion provision.

A decision that resolves these questions would provide far more useful guidance than an abstract endorsement of either flexibility or rigidity.

Judicial humility and the limits of doctrinal revision

There is also a jurisprudential issue concerning the appropriate role of an intermediate appellate court.

The Sixth District’s willingness to examine precedent critically is not itself objectionable. Courts should not perpetuate error merely because it is old. Nor should an intermediate appellate court be prohibited from identifying a genuine conflict between established interpretations and controlling Supreme Court holdings.

But the manner of correction matters. When an intermediate court concludes that every other district has misunderstood a foundational Supreme Court decision for decades, the claim warrants especially careful consideration of what those courts were attempting to accomplish and whether the asserted error was truly necessary to the case at hand.

That caution is particularly appropriate here because the Sixth District could affirm the exclusion of the experts without discarding the traditional prejudice framework. Judge Smith’s concurrence demonstrates as much. The trial court itself found prejudice, and the record contained substantial evidence supporting that determination. The decision did not arise from an otherwise unexplained exclusion of evidence where no meaningful unfairness had been identified.

The broader holding thus extends beyond the practical needs of the dispute.

It may also generate the very uncertainty that the court sought to eliminate. A litigant facing exclusion in one district may invoke a traditional Binger analysis, while another litigant in the Sixth District confronts a rule under which a prejudice finding is not a prerequisite. The importance of expert testimony and the consequences of nondisclosure should not vary in fundamental ways merely because a case is filed on one side of an appellate district boundary.

The Florida Supreme Court should use the opportunity presented by Wynn to restore statewide clarity. It need not reject the importance of strict case management to do so. It can insist on meaningful compliance with deadlines while articulating a coherent relationship between disclosure obligations, available sanctions, actual prejudice, and the preservation of fair trials.

Most importantly, the Court should resist equating a trial judge’s power to enforce an order with an obligation—or an unrestricted preference—to impose the most consequential available sanction.

The Trial Should Remain the Center of Civil Litigation

The modern civil justice system contains an increasingly powerful contradiction.

Its constitutional and historical foundations contemplate the adjudication of genuine disputes through evidence presented to an independent factfinder. Its procedural architecture was designed to simplify the presentation of claims and defenses, abolish unnecessary technical forms, encourage disclosure, and facilitate decisions on the merits. Yet its daily operation often requires lawyers to devote extraordinary attention to procedural administration, while increasingly significant questions are resolved through pretrial motions, sanctions, and evidentiary exclusions.

Some of this development is unavoidable. Modern litigation involves enormous quantities of information, specialized expertise, substantial expense, and legitimate demands for efficiency. Courts cannot function without enforceable procedures, and lawyers have no entitlement to disregard those procedures because their practices are busy or their clients are difficult.

The objection is not to the existence of rules. It is to the gradual inversion of their purpose.

The law should not become a system in which the preservation of administrative order routinely receives greater weight than the presentation of material evidence, the testing of opposing testimony, and the resolution of factual disputes by juries. Those activities are not ornamental features of litigation. They are among its central justifications.

The distinction can be understood through a simple example. Suppose a party identifies a material expert opinion shortly after a disclosure deadline, with substantial time remaining before trial. The opposing party already knows the expert’s identity, understands the subject matter, and can take a deposition without affecting the trial schedule. The disclosure was late, and the responsible lawyer should be required to explain why. Costs or other proportionate remedies may be appropriate.

But if the court excludes the opinion solely because the deadline passed, without considering whether admission would compromise fairness, the resulting trial may be procedurally orderly and substantively incomplete.

Now consider the opposite case. A lawyer conceals an important expert theory until the eve of trial. The opposing party would need new technical analysis to respond, and allowing the opinion would either impair the opponent’s case or force the court to postpone a long-scheduled trial. Exclusion may be necessary to protect the legitimacy of the proceeding.

Both outcomes can be defended by a single principle: procedure should protect the fairness of adjudication, and its consequences should bear a rational relationship to the interests threatened by noncompliance.

That principle respects the opposing party who prepared diligently. It respects the judge responsible for administering a crowded docket. It respects the lawyer whose client has a potentially valid claim or defense. Above all, it respects the jury by recognizing that excluding significant evidence should not be an inconsequential exercise of administrative authority.

The profession should also reconsider how much of a lawyer’s working life is consumed by procedural mechanics of marginal substantive value. Every hour devoted to deciphering redundant filing instructions or adapting an adequate motion to a particular division’s stylistic preferences is an hour unavailable for legal analysis, factual investigation, witness preparation, or client counseling. Technology was supposed to make legal practice more efficient. It should not become the medium through which unnecessary procedural complexity is multiplied.

There is an important distinction between professional discipline and procedural formalism. The first strengthens advocacy and protects clients. The second may simply make the practice of law more difficult without improving the quality of adjudication.

The great attraction of the adversarial courtroom has always been that it entrusts consequential decisions to a process in which evidence can be confronted, assumptions challenged, witnesses examined, and competing interpretations tested. That process is imperfect, sometimes expensive, and often unpredictable. Nevertheless, its imperfections do not justify replacing it with a regime in which the most significant factual disputes are effectively settled by the administration of deadlines.

The lawyer’s ability to conduct a searching cross-examination, expose a flaw in expert reasoning, or persuade a jury through principled argument should remain a meaningful professional skill. Those skills cannot guarantee justice, but they provide methods for pursuing it through the evaluation of evidence. They are not obsolete simply because modern case management has become increasingly sophisticated.

Ultimately, Crecelius is important not because the defendant in that particular case necessarily deserved to present his late-disclosed experts. On the record described by the Sixth District, exclusion was supportable under the traditional prejudice analysis. The significance of the decision is that it advances a legal principle capable of reaching cases in which exclusion cannot be justified by comparable prejudice.

That is the point at which a legitimate demand for compliance threatens to become an independent obstacle to substantive adjudication.

Florida’s Constitution protects access to courts and the civil jury. Its procedural rules reject obsolete technical forms and instruct courts to pursue justice alongside speed and economy. Its common-law tradition recognizes that the law must be applied to the practical circumstances of human disputes. Those principles do not eliminate procedural obligations, but they should guide the interpretation and application of every rule governing access to evidence and trial.

The proper measure of a civil justice system is not how efficiently it enforces its calendar, how uniformly it processes proposed orders, or how many disputes it resolves without a trial. Those considerations matter, but they are subordinate to the purpose for which courts exist.

The measure is whether the system gives parties a fair opportunity to present their cases under governing law and, when genuine factual disputes remain, permits the jury to decide them on a record that has not been unnecessarily diminished by procedural formalism.

That was the promise of modern civil procedure. The Florida Supreme Court should ensure that it remains the governing principle of Florida civil justice.

Administrative Law, Business and History, Business Torts and Contracts, Civil Procedure, Closing Argument, Commercial Litigation, Complex Liability Cases, Constitutional Law, Florida Constitution, Florida Constitutional Law, Government Abuse of Citizenry, Government Law, Law Firm Strategy, Lawyer Ethics, Legal Writing, Local Government Law, Municipal Code Enforcement, Mythology in the Law, Professional Responsibility, Property Rights, Small Business Law, Summary Judgment, Technology & Law, Trial Tactics, United States Constitution

Leave a Reply

Call Donner Law Firm · 407-639-4223