FLORIDA TRIAL COUNSEL · REPRESENTING CLIENTS SINCE 1999Miami · Orlando · Gainesville · Pensacola   |   By appointment

Florida’s Property Insurance Problem Has No Easy Villain — and No Easy Solution

Tropical residential neighborhood with palm trees, modest homes, puddles, and storm clouds

By Jeffrey T. Donner

September 30, 2026

Florida’s property-insurance crisis is often described as though it were principally a problem of misconduct by one set of institutional actors. Insurers point to litigation frequency, fraudulent or inflated claims, public adjusters, reinsurance costs, and regulatory burdens. Policyholders and consumer advocates emphasize claim denials, increasingly restrictive policy language, premium escalation, insurer insolvencies, opaque affiliate transactions, and perceived regulatory failure. Political actors select among these explanations according to ideology and constituency. Each account identifies real features of the market, but none adequately captures the structural problem confronting Florida: the state is attempting to finance increasingly expensive losses arising from an aging residential housing stock, concentrated catastrophe exposure, high reconstruction costs, and a fragmented insurance architecture that is nominally private but functionally dependent upon pervasive public regulation, state-created risk pools, and governmental backstops.

The central problem is not whether Florida should socialize property risk, because it already does; the real question is how that risk should be priced, allocated, administered, and ultimately borne when the underlying physical losses cannot be eliminated by statute, litigation reform, regulatory intervention, or political rhetoric.

The Aging Housing Stock Is the Starting Point

Any serious analysis should begin with the physical asset being insured. Consider an ordinary Florida house constructed in 1978 or 1980. At the time of construction, its plumbing, electrical system, roof assembly, windows, air-conditioning equipment, waterproofing, and structural components were new. Four and a half decades later, that same house may remain economically valuable, and in many Florida markets may be worth several times its original purchase price, but it is no longer physically equivalent to a newly constructed residence. Its market appreciation may reflect land scarcity, population growth, neighborhood desirability, inflation, or broader housing-market conditions, while its underlying mechanical and structural systems have continued to age.

That distinction is central to insurance underwriting because market value and physical risk are not the same thing. A forty-five-year-old plumbing system presents a different expected-loss profile from a newly installed system. The same is true of roofs, electrical panels, wiring, HVAC systems, waterproofing, and prior repairs. Insurance companies therefore evaluate the age and condition of these components because they affect both the probability and severity of future loss. There is nothing inherently improper about doing so. It is actuarial discrimination in the literal and legitimate sense of distinguishing among materially different risk characteristics.

The legal difficulty arises because a homeowner experiences loss in concrete rather than actuarial terms. A pipe ruptures. Water damages cabinetry, flooring, drywall, and personal property. From the homeowner’s perspective, something unexpected and financially serious has happened, and that is precisely why insurance was purchased. The insurer, however, must ask a narrower contractual question: whether the loss falls within the specific allocation of risk expressed in the policy. Was the event sudden or gradual? Was the failed component itself covered? Was ensuing damage covered even if the component that failed was excluded? Did deterioration, wear and tear, repeated leakage, defective maintenance, or another exclusion apply? Did a deductible, sublimit, or depreciation provision materially reduce the recovery?

The policy therefore does not function as a generalized warranty against the economic consequences of owning an aging structure. It is a contract that transfers specified fortuitous risks while leaving other risks with the owner. If insurance were required to absorb ordinary depreciation, deferred maintenance, and predictable component failure, premiums would have to reflect those costs. The system would begin to move away from insuring uncertain losses and toward financing routine capital replacement. That may be a policy choice society could make, but it would be something materially different from conventional property insurance.

Having practiced in the first-party property arena, I have seen claims that warranted serious challenge to an insurer’s position, but I have also seen claims in which, after reviewing the policy language, the cause of loss, and the amount paid, the carrier’s position was contractually defensible. I have encountered that reality even with claims involving my own property. That experience makes it difficult to accept the simplistic proposition that Florida’s insurance problem can be solved merely by forcing insurers to pay more claims. An insurer that systematically pays losses outside the scope of its contractual obligations does not make those costs disappear; it redistributes them through higher premiums, reduced capital, diminished returns to investors, or eventual insolvency.

Insurance Is a Mechanism for Collective Risk Allocation

Insurance is often described as a private contract, but economically it is also a mechanism for collective risk allocation. Policyholders contribute premiums into a common pool. Most will receive less in claims than they pay over any particular period, while a smaller number will suffer losses far exceeding their individual contributions. The economic function of insurance is therefore to transfer and pool low-frequency, high-severity risk across a broader population. In that sense, insurance necessarily contains an element of redistribution, although the word should not be treated as pejorative. A homeowner whose property does not burn contributes toward the losses of the homeowner whose property does. Drivers who avoid catastrophic accidents contribute toward the liabilities generated by those who do not. Property owners outside the path of a hurricane contribute toward the claims of those whose homes are destroyed.

The important policy question is therefore not whether risk will be socialized to some degree. It necessarily will be if insurance is to exist at all. The more serious questions concern the breadth of the risk pool, the accuracy with which risk is differentiated, the degree of cross-subsidization that is acceptable, the amount of loss that should remain with the insured, and the institutional mechanism through which the transfer occurs. These questions become especially important in Florida because catastrophic residential property risk is not confined to ordinary private insurance markets.

The Florida Hurricane Catastrophe Fund provides state-created reinsurance to participating residential property insurers. Private carriers pay premiums to the Fund, and the Fund reimburses qualifying hurricane losses above contractual retention levels. In practical terms, the state has created a mechanism that assumes a layer of catastrophic risk that otherwise would have to remain with primary insurers or be transferred to global reinsurers. Citizens Property Insurance Corporation performs a related but distinct function by providing insurance where private-market availability is inadequate. The existence of both institutions reflects a legislative judgment that the state cannot simply permit ordinary market forces to determine whether all residential property remains insurable after severe market disruption.

Once those institutions are incorporated into the analysis, the familiar distinction between “private insurance” and “government insurance” becomes analytically incomplete. Florida has constructed a hybrid system in which private firms write policies and adjust claims, but the state regulates solvency, reviews rates, controls aspects of underwriting, creates residual-market coverage, and participates directly in catastrophe-risk financing. The market is therefore neither genuinely laissez-faire nor fully public. It is an administratively constructed public-private system for allocating and financing property risk.

That point is important because much of the political debate assumes a cleaner ideological division than actually exists. Those who favor private markets often speak as though Florida homeowners insurance is primarily a matter of voluntary contracting among private actors, while critics sometimes speak as though the state stands outside the market and merely fails to regulate it sufficiently. Neither description is accurate. Government is already embedded in the system at nearly every consequential level, and the relevant question is not whether the state should participate but how its participation should be structured.

The Affiliate-Payment Controversy and the Problem of Related-Party Transactions

The current controversy concerning insurer payments to affiliated entities illustrates why solvency regulation necessarily extends beyond claims handling and rate approval. Florida law requires that payments by insurers to affiliates be fair and reasonable. Section 624.424(13), Florida Statutes, authorizes regulatory examination of those transactions and directs attention to the actual cost of services being provided. The rationale is straightforward: related-party transactions are structurally different from arm’s-length transactions because common ownership can weaken the ordinary market discipline that would otherwise constrain price.

An insurer may have entirely legitimate reasons to contract with an affiliated managing general agent, claims administrator, technology company, or management entity. Modern corporate groups routinely separate functions among subsidiaries for operational, tax, liability, and regulatory reasons. The mere fact that an insurer pays money to an affiliate therefore proves nothing improper. The regulatory issue concerns the economic substance and pricing of the transaction.

Suppose a regulated insurer generates $30 million before management expenses. An affiliated company performs services reasonably worth $10 million. If the insurer pays $10 million, the transaction may be entirely conventional. If it pays $30 million for services that would cost $10 million in an arm’s-length market, however, the economic consequences are different. The regulated insurer’s reported profitability declines, its available capital may be reduced, and value migrates to another entity within the same corporate family. Because the regulated insurer is the entity legally obligated to satisfy policyholder claims and maintain sufficient surplus, the distinction is not merely one of accounting presentation.

That is the conceptual significance of the recently disclosed consultant analysis concerning affiliate transactions. The analysis identified circumstances in which regulated insurers reported weak financial performance while affiliated entities received substantial payments and generated profits. The Office of Insurance Regulation has disputed aspects of the report’s methodology and reliability, and those objections should be taken seriously. A disputed consultant analysis is not equivalent to a judicial finding of fraud, unlawful dividends, or improper extraction of capital.

At the same time, the existence of those disputes does not make the underlying regulatory question disappear. When a regulated insurer reports losses while an entity under common ownership earns substantial fees from that insurer, regulators are justified in asking whether those fees reflect the market value of legitimate services or instead transfer economic return away from the regulated risk-bearing entity. That inquiry is especially important because insurance regulation has long restricted the ability of carriers to weaken their own capital position through dividends and other distributions. If affiliate compensation can produce economically similar effects, then scrutiny of those transactions is not an ideological attack on business; it is an ordinary extension of solvency regulation and conflict-of-interest analysis.

The 2026 legislative controversy surrounding affiliate payments should therefore be understood in those institutional terms. The issue is not whether profitable affiliates are inherently suspect, nor whether every payment to a related company conceals misconduct. The question is whether Florida’s existing regulatory framework gives the state sufficient information and authority to distinguish legitimate compensation from transactions that may erode the capital of the insurer actually responsible for paying claims. That is a technical question of regulatory design, and it deserves a more serious answer than the political shorthand of either “insurance-company corruption” or “government overreach.”

Regulation Cannot Eliminate the Underlying Loss

Even perfect regulation of affiliate transactions would not resolve Florida’s property-insurance problem. The same is true of litigation reform, fraud reduction, restrictions on public adjusters, more aggressive claims regulation, or wholesale conversion to public insurance. Each reform can alter costs, incentives, and the distribution of loss, sometimes materially, but none can eliminate the underlying physical damage.

Florida contains an enormous stock of residential real estate exposed to wind, flood, fire, water intrusion, plumbing failure, roof failure, electrical failure, and ordinary deterioration. When damage occurs, economic resources must be devoted to repair or replacement. Labor must be hired, materials purchased, damaged components removed, structures dried, roofs replaced, interiors rebuilt, and sometimes entire houses reconstructed. Those are real resource costs, and no change in legal doctrine can make them vanish.

The resulting loss must therefore be absorbed somewhere in the system. It may remain with the homeowner through deductibles, exclusions, uninsured loss, or depreciation. It may be transferred to a primary insurer. The insurer may transfer part of the risk to a reinsurer. Investors may contribute capital in exchange for an expected return. Other policyholders may contribute through premiums. Government may finance losses through taxes, assessments, guarantees, or emergency appropriations. Capital markets may temporarily finance those obligations through debt or catastrophe-linked securities. Borrowing, however, does not eliminate the loss; it merely reallocates payment across time.

This is the fundamental constraint that should govern every serious insurance proposal. Public policy can determine who bears a loss, when the cost is recognized, and how broadly it is distributed. It cannot abolish the loss itself. The most important question is therefore not whether a proposed reform “lowers insurance costs” in the abstract, but whose costs it lowers, whose costs it increases, and whether the shift is economically transparent.

Wind, Flood, and the Cost of Institutional Fragmentation

The division between wind and flood coverage illustrates the costs created by institutional fragmentation. Most homeowners policies exclude flood, while flood coverage is obtained separately, frequently through the National Flood Insurance Program. This separation has historical and actuarial justifications, particularly because flood risk is geographically concentrated and susceptible to severe adverse selection. Separate treatment permits different underwriting, pricing, subsidies, and land-use signals.

Yet the distinction can become artificial at the point of loss. A hurricane is a single meteorological event capable of producing wind damage, wind-driven rain, storm surge, flooding, structural openings, and sequential or concurrent causes of damage. The legal system may nevertheless be required to determine which component of loss resulted from which peril because different contracts and governmental programs bear different portions of the financial responsibility.

That fragmentation creates substantial transaction costs. Adjusters must allocate damage among causes. Engineers and meteorologists may be retained to reconstruct the sequence of events. Lawyers litigate causation, exclusions, and concurrent-loss doctrines. Courts must interpret overlapping policy provisions. The administrative cost of deciding who pays can therefore become substantial even before the underlying property damage itself is repaired.

From an economic perspective, this raises a legitimate institutional-design question: whether catastrophe risk should continue to be divided among private homeowners carriers, federal flood insurance, state catastrophe reinsurance, residual-market coverage, private reinsurance, and supplemental products. There are substantial arguments in favor of separation. Risk-based pricing may be more accurate when distinct perils are separately underwritten, and keeping flood exposure visible may discourage overdevelopment in exceptionally hazardous areas. But there are also costs to maintaining multiple overlapping systems. A serious analysis should compare those costs rather than assuming that the existing architecture is efficient merely because it evolved historically.

A Fully Public Insurance Model

The most radical alternative would be to place primary residential catastrophe insurance principally within a public institution. Florida could theoretically establish a statewide property insurer funded through premiums, taxes, assessments, or some combination of the three. It could stratify contributions by property value, geography, mitigation, construction characteristics, or income; accumulate reserves; purchase global reinsurance; issue catastrophe bonds; and maintain statutory mechanisms for extraordinary losses. Private insurers could remain as providers of supplemental coverage or leave the primary residential market altogether.

Such a model would fundamentally alter the institutional structure, but it would not alter the underlying quantity of risk. The same buildings would remain exposed to the same hurricanes, plumbing failures, fires, floods, and construction costs. The state would simply become the principal financial intermediary through which those risks were pooled and paid. The relevant policy question would therefore be whether public administration could allocate and finance those risks more efficiently, transparently, or equitably than a regulated private market.

There are plausible advantages to such a system. A public insurer might reduce certain acquisition expenses, marketing costs, duplicative corporate structures, and private profit margins. A single statewide purchaser could possess substantial bargaining power in the reinsurance and capital markets. A broader tax base could also permit catastrophe losses to be spread beyond homeowners alone, which might reduce the volatility of insurance premiums for individual properties.

The disadvantages are equally substantial. Political decision-makers may underprice risk for electoral reasons, particularly when actuarially sound rates would impose visible burdens on voters. Cross-subsidies may become difficult to identify and politically entrenched. Lower-risk inland homeowners may subsidize more expensive coastal risks, renters and non-property owners may be required to support benefits accruing principally to homeowners, and politically suppressed pricing may encourage continued development in areas where accurate risk signals would otherwise discourage it. Private insurance imposes a degree of market discipline because persistent mispricing eventually consumes capital; a public system can defer that reckoning longer through taxation and borrowing, but it cannot escape it indefinitely.

The meaningful distinction is therefore not between a costly private system and a costless public one. It is between different institutional mechanisms for distributing the same expected losses, each of which creates different incentives, administrative burdens, and distributive consequences.

Moral Hazard, Adverse Selection, and Claims Behavior

Any serious insurance analysis must also account for behavioral incentives. Insurance changes behavior because it separates the person experiencing a loss from the person ultimately bearing the full financial cost. Economists describe one consequence as moral hazard: once insurance exists, insureds and other participants may have weaker incentives to minimize certain costs because some portion of those costs will be transferred to the insurer.

In property insurance, that problem can arise at multiple levels. Contractors may have incentives to increase the scope or price of repairs when an insurer is expected to pay. Public adjusters may maximize claim valuation because their compensation depends on recovery. Lawyers may litigate disputes that would be uneconomical if the homeowner alone bore the cost. Some homeowners may characterize preexisting deterioration as accidental loss. None of these incentives means that claims are generally fraudulent; they are predictable features of third-party payment systems.

Adverse selection presents a different problem. People facing greater risk have stronger incentives to purchase insurance, which can destabilize a market if insurers cannot accurately differentiate among risks or charge prices reflecting those differences. Government programs can mitigate adverse selection by broadening participation, but they can also obscure price signals if premiums are intentionally disconnected from underlying risk.

This is why risk-based pricing serves not only a revenue function but an informational one. A high premium communicates that a particular property, location, construction type, or behavior is expensive to insure. If public policy chooses to suppress that signal, there may be legitimate reasons for doing so, but the subsidy should be acknowledged rather than disguised. Otherwise, the system can encourage precisely the behavior that generates greater future losses.

The Tax Question Is Really a Question of Incidence

The same analytical framework applies to taxation. Florida’s lack of a personal state income tax is often treated as though it means Floridians have avoided a category of public cost. In reality, every public system must be financed somehow. If the state does not rely on personal income taxation, it must rely more heavily on sales taxes, property taxes, corporate taxes, fees, assessments, tourism-related revenue, insurance-related charges, and federal transfers.

A decision to finance catastrophe risk through homeowners premiums rather than general taxation is therefore not a decision between payment and nonpayment. It is a decision about the incidence of payment. If Florida chose to fund a larger portion of catastrophic property losses through general taxation, some homeowners might pay lower premiums but higher taxes. Other taxpayers might bear costs they currently do not bear directly, and the burden would shift according to the design of the tax system.

That would raise unavoidable distributional questions. Should a renter help finance reconstruction of an oceanfront residence? Should a lower-risk inland homeowner subsidize a higher-risk coastal property? Should higher-income taxpayers bear a greater share of catastrophe losses? Should premiums be strictly actuarial, or should insurance also serve redistributive social objectives? These are not merely actuarial questions. They are normative questions about fairness, incentives, and political economy.

The same point applies to housing values. It is tempting to assume that replacing high insurance premiums with higher taxes would simply reduce the total cost of homeownership, but markets would adjust in complicated ways. Property values capitalize recurring costs. Wages, migration, tax burdens, insurance premiums, and housing demand would all respond to a materially different system. It is therefore more accurate to say that a new financing structure would redistribute costs than to assume that it would eliminate them.

Fraud Exists, but So Does Genuine Catastrophic Loss

Florida’s insurance system is unquestionably affected by opportunistic behavior. Some losses are exaggerated. Some claims are fraudulent. Some contractors inflate repair estimates. Some policyholders characterize preexisting deterioration as accidental damage. Some lawsuits lack merit. These practices increase claim costs and ultimately affect premiums, reinsurance pricing, and insurer capital requirements.

But the existence of moral hazard should not be confused with the nonexistence of genuine loss. Hurricanes destroy structures. Pipes rupture. Roofs fail. Fires occur. Water intrusion can render homes uninhabitable. Families can suffer losses far beyond their capacity to self-insure. The economic justification for insurance remains powerful precisely because those events occur unpredictably and can be financially catastrophic.

A rational insurance system must therefore perform two functions simultaneously: resist opportunistic and non-covered claims while reliably paying legitimate covered losses. That balancing problem is inherently difficult. A system that emphasizes claim suppression too aggressively creates underpayment and undermines the value of insurance. A system that pays too liberally increases moral hazard, raises premiums, and weakens solvency. There is no regulatory design that completely eliminates this tension, which is why claims administration will remain controversial under virtually any institutional arrangement.

Why Insurer Conduct Still Matters

None of this should be understood as a defense of insurers from regulatory scrutiny. Insurance markets present special problems because policyholders prepay for contingent future performance and cannot realistically monitor insurer solvency, reserving practices, investment policy, reinsurance protection, affiliate transactions, or capital allocation. Those information asymmetries justify forms of governmental oversight that would be unnecessary in many ordinary commercial transactions.

The insurer-policyholder relationship also becomes adversarial at precisely the moment when the insured is most economically vulnerable. A homeowner who has paid premiums for twenty years may reasonably regard a catastrophic loss as the moment at which the insurer should perform its side of the bargain. The insurer, however, is not asked merely whether the homeowner suffered an economic loss; it must determine whether that loss falls within the contractual promise for which premium was collected. Those are different questions, and the distinction explains why even legitimate claim administration can feel adversarial.

The appropriate regulatory objective is therefore neither hostility to insurers nor deference to them. An insurer does not act improperly merely because it enforces an exclusion, applies a deductible, disputes causation, or refuses to insure a risk at a price it regards as inadequate. At the same time, an insurer should not be permitted to weaken the risk-bearing entity through opaque related-party transfers, manipulate claims practices to avoid legitimate contractual obligations, or rely on complexity and information asymmetry in ways that defeat regulatory protections. The objective should be institutional discipline: accurate underwriting, adequate capitalization, fair claims administration, transparent related-party transactions, and enforceable contractual obligations.

Florida Already Operates a Hybrid System

For all the ideological language surrounding insurance policy, Florida has already rejected both pure alternatives. It has rejected laissez-faire insurance because private carriers operate under pervasive statutory and regulatory supervision. It has also rejected fully public property insurance because private capital, underwriting, reinsurance, and claims administration remain central to the system.

What exists instead is a layered structure of private contracting, public regulation, state-supported risk sharing, and capital-market transfer. Private insurers write policies and adjust claims. State regulators supervise solvency and rates. Citizens provides residual coverage. The Florida Hurricane Catastrophe Fund supplies a state-created layer of catastrophe reinsurance. Federal institutions support flood insurance. Private global reinsurers distribute portions of Florida hurricane risk internationally. Capital markets absorb additional catastrophe exposure through specialized financial instruments. After extraordinary disasters, government provides emergency assistance, infrastructure spending, loans, and other forms of support.

The meaningful policy question is therefore not whether government should participate in Florida property insurance. Government already participates at every important level. The more difficult questions are how much risk government should assume, how accurately risk should be priced, how transparent subsidies should be, how much loss should remain with individual property owners, and whether private intermediaries provide sufficient value to justify their costs and profits.

Those questions cannot be answered by ideology alone. A state-run system could reduce some transaction costs while creating political pricing distortions. A private system could improve risk differentiation while imposing higher administrative costs and profit requirements. A hybrid system can capture some advantages of each while also inheriting many of their weaknesses. The proper inquiry is comparative rather than rhetorical: which institutional arrangement produces the best combination of solvency, affordability, transparency, incentives, and administrative efficiency under Florida’s actual conditions?

The Unavoidable Conclusion

Florida’s property-insurance debate becomes clearer once it is stripped of the assumption that some legal or political reform can make the underlying cost disappear. There is no statutory reform that can make aging housing stock physically new, no litigation reform that can eliminate hurricane exposure, no regulatory crackdown that can make reinsurance costless, and no public insurance program that can eliminate the real resources required to rebuild damaged property. Likewise, no private insurer can indefinitely pay claims and expenses exceeding premiums, investment income, and available capital.

Public policy can, however, alter the distribution of those losses. Florida can place more risk on individual homeowners through deductibles and exclusions, spread more risk through private insurance, assume more risk through Citizens or the Catastrophe Fund, purchase more reinsurance, finance extraordinary losses through assessments or general taxation, subsidize mitigation, discourage development in exceptionally hazardous areas, regulate affiliate transactions more aggressively, and reconsider the institutional separation between wind and flood coverage. Each choice has different effects on incentives, affordability, solvency, and distribution.

The central issue is therefore not whether Florida can avoid paying for property risk. It cannot. The issue is who pays, by what mechanism, under what rules, and with what degree of transparency. A system financed principally through actuarially priced premiums will distribute costs differently from one financed partly through broad taxation. A system that leaves more loss with homeowners will create stronger individual incentives but greater financial hardship. A system that spreads losses broadly may increase affordability for high-risk properties while creating subsidies borne by lower-risk households.

Seen in those terms, Florida’s property-insurance crisis is not fundamentally a morality play about virtuous homeowners and predatory insurers, or prudent insurers and dishonest claimants. It is a problem of risk allocation, institutional design, and political economy arising from a simple physical fact: Florida contains a vast and aging stock of valuable property exposed to unusually severe and correlated hazards.

The state can choose among competing methods of financing that risk, and some choices may prove substantially better than others. What it cannot do is choose not to bear the cost at all.

Administrative Law, First Party Property Law, Government Abuse of Citizenry, Government Law, Insurance Company Bad Faith, Insurance Law
Call Donner Law Firm · 407-639-4223