
Proceedings supplementary, fraudulent transfers, third-party discovery, and the increasingly important problem of delay
By Jeffrey T. Donner
September 29, 2026
A judgment is not money. It is a judicial determination that one party owes another party money, and in difficult cases the real litigation begins only after the judgment has been entered. A debtor who intends to pay may satisfy the judgment voluntarily. A debtor who does not intend to pay may empty accounts, move property, transfer assets to relatives or affiliated companies, convert money to cash, or place assets beyond the creditor’s immediate reach. At that point, conventional collection efforts may be inadequate because the central question is no longer merely what the judgment debtor owns today. The more important question may be what happened to property the debtor owned yesterday.
Florida law provides substantial remedies for creditors confronting that problem, but those remedies are procedurally technical and increasingly time-sensitive.
Proceedings Supplementary Under Section 56.29
Florida Statute § 56.29 provides the principal statutory framework for proceedings supplementary to execution. Under the current statute, a judgment creditor holding an unsatisfied judgment or judgment lien may file a motion and affidavit identifying the judgment, the case number, the unsatisfied amount including accrued costs and interest, and stating that execution is valid and outstanding. Once those statutory prerequisites are satisfied, the judgment creditor is entitled to proceedings supplementary. Fla. Stat. § 56.29(1).
The significance of proceedings supplementary is that they permit the court to look beyond the named judgment debtor. If the creditor identifies nonexempt property of the debtor in another person’s hands, or property, debts, or other obligations due to the debtor that may be applied toward satisfaction of the judgment, the creditor may invoke the procedures provided by the statute. Section 56.29(2) authorizes the use of a Notice to Appear directed to a third party and requires the property, debt, or obligation at issue to be described with reasonable particularity. The statute also preserves the third party’s right to assert defenses and contemplates discovery under the Florida Rules of Civil Procedure. Fla. Stat. § 56.29(2).
Proceedings supplementary therefore are not merely another version of garnishment. They provide a statutory mechanism for determining whether property outside the debtor’s immediate possession may nevertheless be reached to satisfy the judgment. Section 56.29(6) authorizes the court, in appropriate circumstances, to order property applied toward satisfaction of the judgment and to enter such orders, judgments, and writs as are necessary to carry out the proceeding. Section 56.29(9) separately provides that claims concerning the judgment debtor’s assets under Chapter 726 may be litigated within proceedings supplementary through a supplemental complaint.
The Difference Between Proving a Withdrawal and Proving a Transfer
One of the most important distinctions in post-judgment asset litigation is the difference between showing that money left the debtor and showing where it went.
Suppose a bank statement proves that a debtor withdrew $200,000 in cash while litigation was pending. That fact may be highly significant. It may justify further investigation and may ultimately become circumstantial evidence of an effort to frustrate collection. But the withdrawal itself does not establish that the debtor gave the money to a sibling, deposited it into an affiliated company, purchased property through a nominee, or transferred it to any other identifiable person. The creditor still must prove the next transaction.
That distinction affects both liability and discovery strategy. A creditor may need teller records, wire-transfer information, canceled checks, account-opening documents, title records, purchase records, loan applications, business records, communications, testimony, or recipient-side financial records before a particular transferee can responsibly be accused of receiving debtor property. The strongest enforcement cases are built by connecting the source side of the transaction to the destination side rather than assuming that suspicious timing alone proves the recipient.
This is also why targeted discovery is generally preferable to indiscriminate discovery. The objective is not to subpoena every relative or business associate of the debtor merely because a relationship exists. The objective is to identify transactions and property with sufficient factual specificity to justify compulsory process and, ultimately, judicial relief.
Fraudulent Transfers Under Chapter 726
Florida Statute § 726.105 provides that a transfer is fraudulent as to a creditor when the debtor makes the transfer with actual intent to hinder, delay, or defraud a creditor. The statute also recognizes specified constructive-transfer theories involving inadequate value and the debtor’s financial condition. Fla. Stat. § 726.105(1).
Because direct evidence of fraudulent intent is uncommon, § 726.105(2) identifies circumstances that may be considered in determining intent. These include transfers to insiders, concealment, transfers made after the debtor has been sued or threatened with suit, transfers involving substantially all of the debtor’s assets, inadequate consideration, insolvency, removal or concealment of assets, and transfers occurring shortly before or shortly after a substantial debt was incurred. Fla. Stat. § 726.105(2).
These traditional “badges of fraud” do not make every transfer to a relative fraudulent. Nor does the existence of one suspicious circumstance eliminate the need for proof. The inquiry is fact-intensive. A transfer for reasonably equivalent value in an ordinary transaction is materially different from a transfer of substantial assets to an insider for little or no consideration after litigation has already begun.
Chapter 726 provides significant remedies when a qualifying transfer is established. Section 726.108 permits avoidance of the transfer to the extent necessary to satisfy the creditor’s claim, attachment or other provisional relief, injunctions against further disposition, appointment of a receiver where appropriate, and other relief the circumstances may require. If the creditor already has a judgment, the statute also permits execution on the transferred asset or its proceeds if the court so orders. Fla. Stat. § 726.108.
Dissipation of the original property does not necessarily eliminate all relief. Section 726.109 permits, subject to statutory defenses and limitations, a judgment for the value of the transferred asset or the amount necessary to satisfy the creditor’s claim, whichever is less. Depending upon the circumstances, liability may extend to the first transferee or the person for whose benefit the transfer was made, and in some circumstances to subsequent transferees. The statute also protects qualifying good-faith transferees and recognizes other defenses. Fla. Stat. § 726.109.
The Timeliness Problem
The most dangerous mistake in an old judgment-enforcement matter is assuming that because the judgment remains enforceable, every fraudulent-transfer remedy necessarily remains available for the same period.
Section 726.110 establishes extinguishment periods for claims under Chapter 726. A claim under § 726.105(1)(a), based on actual intent to hinder, delay, or defraud a creditor, must generally be brought within four years after the transfer was made or the obligation incurred, or, if later, within one year after the transfer or obligation was or reasonably could have been discovered by the claimant. Claims under § 726.105(1)(b) and § 726.106(1) generally must be brought within four years, while a claim under § 726.106(2) must generally be brought within one year. Fla. Stat. § 726.110.
The date of the debtor’s bank withdrawal is not necessarily the date of the legally relevant transfer. Florida Statute § 726.107 separately addresses when a transfer is made or an obligation incurred. Depending upon the property and transaction involved, the operative transfer date may differ from the date cash was withdrawn from a bank account.
That distinction can be outcome-determinative. If a debtor withdraws money in January but does not transfer it to another person until months later, the withdrawal date and transfer date are not necessarily the same. Likewise, learning that a relative received boxes, computers, or other tangible property does not automatically establish that the creditor knew or reasonably should have known about a separate cash transfer. The timeliness inquiry must therefore be tied to the actual transaction being challenged.
McGregor v. Fowler White Burnett, P.A.
The Fourth District’s decision in McGregor v. Fowler White Burnett, P.A., 332 So. 3d 481 (Fla. 4th DCA 2021), is an important modern decision addressing the interaction between proceedings supplementary and Chapter 726.
In McGregor, the judgment creditors sought relief arising from transfers that had occurred years earlier. The Fourth District concluded that the monetary fraudulent-transfer relief sought by the creditors was governed by the Chapter 726 mechanism incorporated into § 56.29 and was therefore subject to Chapter 726’s extinguishment provisions. The court rejected the argument that § 56.29(3)(b) independently permitted the creditors to obtain the monetary relief they sought without regard to Chapter 726’s time limits. McGregor, 332 So. 3d at 488–91.
For practitioners, the significance of McGregor is straightforward: an old judgment does not necessarily preserve every remedy relating to an old transfer. The age of the transaction, the date of discovery, the nature of the requested relief, and the particular statutory mechanism invoked all matter.
Rosenberg v. U.S. Bank, N.A.
The Third District took a materially different approach in Rosenberg v. U.S. Bank, N.A., 360 So. 3d 795 (Fla. 3d DCA 2023).
There, the judgment creditor pursued proceedings supplementary involving a transfer of a judgment owned by the judgment debtor to a family trust. The Third District concluded that § 56.29(3) provided a remedy distinct from a Chapter 726 cause of action and rejected the contention that the particular proceedings-supplementary remedy was extinguished under § 726.110. The court also upheld the availability of monetary relief in the supplementary proceeding. Rosenberg, 360 So. 3d at 799–803.
The Third District expressly disagreed with the reasoning adopted in McGregor. That disagreement is significant because it affects whether some remedies arising from older transfers may remain available during the life of a judgment or instead are subject to Chapter 726’s shorter extinguishment periods.
Saadi v. Maroun and the Pending Florida Supreme Court Review
The conflict has now reached the Florida Supreme Court through the Eleventh Circuit’s decision in Saadi v. Maroun, 157 F.4th 1353 (11th Cir. 2025).
In Saadi, the judgment creditor had obtained a federal judgment years earlier and later alleged that the debtor had transferred funds to a related company. The Eleventh Circuit concluded that several dispositive questions of Florida law remained unsettled and certified five questions to the Florida Supreme Court. Among them are whether a judgment creditor may obtain a money judgment against a transferee under § 56.29(3)(b), the scope of property that may be reached under that subsection, whether the 2014 and 2016 amendments to § 56.29 may be applied retroactively, and related tolling questions. Saadi, 157 F.4th at 1365–72.
The Eleventh Circuit expressly recognized the conflicting approaches of McGregor and Rosenberg and declined to predict which interpretation the Florida Supreme Court would adopt. The Florida Supreme Court accepted the certified questions in Case No. SC2025-1675 and heard oral argument on September 9, 2026. As of this writing, the Court has not issued a decision.
For lawyers handling older judgments, Saadi is not an academic dispute. The eventual decision may materially affect which remedies remain available against transferees and how Florida courts analyze older transfers in proceedings supplementary.
Martinez v. Price for Limo, LLC: Why the Prior Docket Matters
The Fourth District’s 2026 decision in Martinez v. Price for Limo, LLC, Nos. 4D2025-1072, 4D2025-1073 & 4D2025-1075 (Fla. 4th DCA July 1, 2026), illustrates a separate but related point: before concluding that a Chapter 726 claim is untimely, counsel must examine exactly what prior enforcement filings were made.
The judgment creditors in Martinez filed a motion to commence proceedings supplementary in June 2021. They later filed supplemental complaints under Chapter 726 in August 2024. The trial court dismissed the supplemental complaints as time-barred. The Fourth District reversed, holding that the supplemental complaints related back to the earlier motion to commence proceedings supplementary because they arose from the same conduct, transactions, or occurrences identified in the earlier proceeding.
The court emphasized that proceedings supplementary are special statutory proceedings and held that the motion commencing the proceeding could function as the equivalent of a pleading for purposes of the relation-back doctrine. Martinez did not hold that every alleged transfer was necessarily timely, and the court expressly limited its holding. It held that the trial court erred in dismissing the supplemental complaints in their entirety and directed that, for limitations purposes on remand, the action be treated as having been brought when the motion to commence proceedings supplementary was filed.
That distinction can be critical in an older enforcement matter. A lawyer who looks only at the date of a later supplemental complaint may reach the wrong conclusion if an earlier proceedings-supplementary filing already placed the relevant transactions before the court.
The First Step in a Difficult Collection Matter Is Often Reconstruction
When a judgment has been outstanding for years and assets appear to have moved, the first task is usually not filing a new complaint. It is reconstructing the existing record.
Counsel should determine the exact unpaid judgment balance, including accrued interest and credits; review writs of execution and garnishment proceedings; confirm judgment-lien status; identify any prior proceedings supplementary; examine Notices to Appear and third-party discovery; and determine whether prior pleadings may affect timeliness or relation-back arguments. If the judgment debtor has died, probate records may also have to be analyzed to determine whether particular property belongs to the estate, a transferee, or some other person. If assets or transferees are located outside Florida, interstate discovery and enforcement issues may also arise.
Only after that reconstruction can counsel intelligently decide what should be filed next.
The financial record requires the same discipline. Large withdrawals may establish that assets disappeared from an obvious collection source, but they do not by themselves prove fraudulent transfers to particular individuals. The effective strategy is to identify the evidentiary gaps, obtain the records necessary to close those gaps, and then direct compulsory process toward the persons and institutions actually connected to the transactions.
Judgment Enforcement Is Litigation
Complex judgment enforcement is not merely debt collection. It can involve financial reconstruction, fraudulent-transfer analysis, proceedings supplementary, nonparty discovery, subpoenas to financial institutions and businesses, depositions, competing ownership claims, probate issues, interstate discovery, provisional remedies, evidentiary hearings, and appellate questions.
The creditor’s objective is not simply to prove that the debtor acted suspiciously. It is to convert admissible evidence into an enforceable remedy against identifiable property or legally responsible persons. That requires an understanding not only of where the money went, but also of the procedural vehicle through which the court can reach it.
Florida provides powerful tools for that purpose. But those tools must be used with precision, particularly where years have passed since the underlying transactions. The interaction of § 56.29, Chapter 726, McGregor, Rosenberg, Martinez, and the pending Florida Supreme Court review in Saadi demonstrates that post-judgment enforcement can present legal questions every bit as sophisticated as the litigation that produced the judgment in the first place.
Donner Law Firm
Donner Law Firm represents clients in complex Florida civil and commercial litigation, including judgment enforcement, debtor-creditor disputes, proceedings supplementary, and litigation involving disputed transfers of property. When a substantial judgment remains unpaid, effective enforcement may require far more than another demand letter or routine garnishment.
To discuss a Florida judgment-enforcement matter, call Donner Law Firm at 407-639-4223 to request a consultation.
